“…For the earlier work, we refer to the remarkable papers of Fraenkel and Berger [18] and Norbury [25,26]. The advantage of a finite dimensional reduction argument, once it can be used, is that solutions concentrating at a saddle points, or concentrating at several points can be constructed [11,12,15]. But if f (y, u) is not C 1 , it is very delicate to use the finite dimensional reduction argument even in the case that f (y, u) is continuous.…”