Lactation in mammals is associated with a period of infertility, which serves to direct maternal metabolic resources towards caring for the newborn offspring rather than supporting another pregnancy. This lactational infertility is characterized by reduced pulsatile luteinizing hormone (LH) secretion and lack of ovulation. The mechanisms mediating suppression of LH secretion during lactation are unclear. There are potential roles for both hormonal cues such as prolactin and progesterone, and pup-derived cues such as suckling, on the inhibition of reproduction. To enable future studies using transgenic animals to investigate these mechanisms, in the present study our aim was to characterize lactational infertility in mice, and to investigate the effect of removing pup-derived cues on LH secretion, time to ovulation and kisspeptin immunoreactivity. We firstly confirmed that C57BL/6J mice experience prolonged anestrus during lactation, which is dependent on establishment of lactation, as removal of pups on the day of parturition led to immediate resumption of pulsatile LH secretion and normal estrous cycles. Once lactation is established, however, the lactational anestrus persisted for several days even after premature removal of pups. Pharmacological suppression of prolactin following premature weaning significantly reduced this period of lactational infertility. Progesterone does not appear to play a significant role in the suppression of fertility during lactation in mice, as levels measured during lactation were not different from non-pregnant mice. These data suggest that prolactin plays a key role in mediating anestrus during early lactation in mice, even in the absence of the suckling stimulus.