Regulatory (Mal)Integration: Its Implications for Migrant Workers’ Ability to Access Employment Rights in Indonesia

Abstract

This paper discusses the understudied situation of legally-resident migrants and their (in)ability to access employment rights that are otherwise available to Indonesians. In our analysis of the relevant institutional architecture and processes, we approach the issue of integration from a regulatory perspective. We used a combination of quantitative and qualitative methods to examine how migrants as high-income workers interface with the labor dispute resolution system in Indonesia. Our findings demonstrate the mal-integrated nature of Indonesia's regulatory system in relation to migration and employment and its consequences for migrant workers' ability to lodge grievances and avail themselves of their employment rights.

Selective Policy Regarding the Granting of Foreign Stay Permits Based on Indonesian State Sovereignty

“…Clothing, Clothing worn by individuals is one aspect considered by Immigration Officers, although it cannot be assessed subjectively and must be supported by other evidence, as mentioned above (Palmer & Piper, 2023). Foreign VVIP and VIP state guests are usually not involved in immigration violations.…”

“…It is explained in these visit visas that they are intended for purposes such as tourism, business, education, employment, or family visits. However, there are numerous cases of foreigners abusing these residence permits for purposes other than those specified in the permits granted by immigration authorities (Palmer & Piper, 2023).…”