Rehabilitating Self-Sacrifice: Care Ethics and the Politics of Resistance

Abstract

How should feminists view acts of self-sacrifice performed by women? According to a long-standing critique of care ethics such acts ought to be viewed with scepticism. Care ethics, it is claimed, celebrates acts of self-sacrifice on the part of carers and in doing so encourages women to choose caring for others over their own selfdevelopment. In doing so, care ethics frustrates attempts to liberate women from the oppression of patriarchy. Care ethicists have responded to this critique by noting limits on the level, form, or scope of self-sacrifice that work to restrict its role in their theories. While we do not here take issue with the initial feminist critiques of selfsacrifice, we suspect that the strategies offered by Care ethicists in response are importantly flawed. Specifically, these responses undervalue the positive roles that self-sacrifice can play in fighting patriarchal oppression. As a result, in attempting to restrict an oppressive norm, these responses risk foreclosing on valuable means of resistance. Our aim is to explore these positive roles for self-sacrifice and thereby rehabilitate its standing with feminists.

Introducing the SMILE_PH method: Sense-making interviews looking at elements of philosophical health

“…In The Hermeneutics of the Subject (2005), Foucault locates the European source of the idea of philosophical health in the Platonic and Socratic conception of ‘epimeleia heautou’, the care for the soul or self. In Plato’s First Alcibiades , a kind of philosophical therapy is a necessary condition to become a good governing actor or citizen via some form of care ethics or even self-sacrifice (Cawston and Archer, 2018). There was a connection between the collective idea of justice and the individual idea of care, and the philosophical self was ultimately not individual: it was an inspirational reconnection with the divine and the sublime in us or entheos (Lampe, 2010: 195), an idea often illustrated by Socrates’ daimon , the personal spirit or voice that was triggering good advice (Silverman, 2010).…”

Tapping into the unimpossible: Philosophical health in lives with spinal cord injury

“…Foucault locates the source of the idea of philosophical health in the Platonic and Socratic conception of ‘epimeleia heautou’, 7 ,p.65 the care for the soul or self. Epistemic care is conceived by Plato as a necessary condition to become a good citizen via healthy embodied ethics 9 . The philosophical self was an inspirational reconnection with the divine and the sublime in us, or entheos , 10 ,p.195, 11 …”

“…Epistemic care is conceived by Plato as a necessary condition to become a good citizen via healthy embodied ethics. 9 The philosophical self was an inspirational reconnection with the divine and the sublime in us, or entheos, 10,p.195,11 What is a truly healthy person if not a mere functioning biological body? 'The True is the whole', writes Hegel in the Phenomenology of Spirit 12,p.11 : philosophy has always been the discipline that attempts to care about a whole rather than some of its parts.…”

Shifting Divine Moral Values in the Novel Rahwana Putih by Sri Teddy Rusdy

“…Moral values have characteristics, namely 1) related to responsibility (Goodale, 2016); 2) related to conscience (Schlegelmilch & Simbrunner, 2018;Goodale, 2016;Balliu, 2015;Suseno, 2005); 3) require (Goodale, 2016;Cawston & Archer 2018;Carbonell, 2018;Tessman, 2018); and 4) formal (Goodale, 2016).…”