Reliability of Semmes-Weinstein Monofilaments and Tuning Fork on Pressure and Vibration Sensation Measurements in Diabetic Patients

Abstract

Sensory neuropathy is the major cause of ulceration in diabetic patients. Periodical sensory examination is an appropriate method to detect neuropathy and decrease the risk of diabetic foot ulcer. Semmes-Weinstein Monofilaments (SWM) and tuning fork on/off test are widely used to assess pressure and vibration sensitivity. The present study evaluated the interand intra-rater reliability of SWM and tuning fork to measure pressure and vibration sensations in diabetic patients. Methods: Following ethical approval, 34 diabetic patients without foot ulceration were recruited. Feet kit SWM and tuning fork were used for pressure and vibration sensation evaluation, respectively. Measurements were performed twice on the first session with an hour interval to assess within-day reliability and the third one was demonstrated 7 days later to assess between-days reliability. Results: Within-day Intra-class Correlation Coefficient (ICC) analysis indicated excellent levels of inter-and intra-rater reliability (ICC>0.75) for feet kit SWM in all foot regions and 128 Hz and 256 Hz tuning forks. Excellent between-days intra-rater reliability (ICC>0.75) was also obtained for SWM; however, the ICC of tuning fork was moderate. Between-days interrater reliability of SWM and tuning fork were high and poor, respectively. Discussion: The obtained results indicated that SWM and tuning fork seemed to be highly reliable to measure pressure and vibration sensations in diabetic patients. However, further studies are required to support the results of current study.

Relationship Between Sensibility Tests and Functional Outcomes in Patients With Traumatic Upper Limb Nerve Injuries: A Systematic Review

“…To help health care professionals select the optimal tests of sensibility, there have been ongoing discussions on the psychometric properties of sensibility tests, such as reliability and validity, in a variety of injuries and other neurologic conditions. 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 However, in the context of upper limb PNI, there still exist uncertainties in choosing the optimal sensibility tests. For example, Jerosch-Herold 4 identified that 2-PD has limited validity and responsiveness yet remains widely used in the PNI setting.…”

Nursing Technology in Vibration Perception Threshold Testing in Diabetic Peripheral Neuropathy Patients

“…The previous study related vibration test by using tuning fork demonstrated that within-day intra-and inter-rater reliability of tuning fork were excellent. However, between-days intra-and inter-rater reliability were moderate and poor, respectively [3].…”

“…Intra-class Correlation Coefficients (ICC) and Standard Error of the Mean (SEM) were calculated to evaluate within and between subject inter and intra rater reliability of 10g Monofilament and Neo-Vibrometer. Based on Rosner's classification, ICC≥0.75 represent excellent, 0.4≤ICC<0.75 indicate fair to good, and <0.4 demonstrate poor reliability [3].…”

“…Monofilament is single fiber nylon threads, used to detect the pressure of sensation in neuropathic patients. Reliability of monofilament has been done by the previous studies [3].…”

A Cloud System Utilized for Diabetic Foot Management

“…Physical protocols such as Semmes-Weinstein Monofilament Examination (SWME), Tuning Fork, and Vibration Perception Thresholds (VPT) are also widely used due to their low cost of tools (Lavery and Armstrong, 2012;Bagherzadeh Cham et al, 2016). Other clinical detective devices liking Quantitative Sensory, Electromyogram and Electrocardiograph, Ergograph, Force Plate, and Plantar Pressure Plate are also used for DPN's evaluate (Lavery et al, 2002;Turgut et al, 2009;Kuhn et al, 2017).…”