Religion and Intergroup Conflict

Abstract

How might religion shape intergroup conflict? We tested whether religious infusion-the extent to which religious rituals and discourse permeate the everyday activities of groups and their members-moderated the effects of two factors known to increase intergroup conflict: competition for limited resources and incompatibility of values held by potentially conflicting groups. We used data from the Global Group Relations Project to investigate 194 groups (e.g., ethnic, religious, national) at 97 sites around the world. When religion was infused in group life, groups were especially prejudiced against those groups that held incompatible values, and they were likely to discriminate against such groups. Moreover, whereas disadvantaged groups with low levels of religious infusion typically avoided directing aggression against their resource-rich and powerful counterparts, disadvantaged groups with high levels of religious infusion directed significant aggression against them-despite the significant tangible costs to the disadvantaged groups potentially posed by enacting such aggression. This research suggests mechanisms through which religion may increase intergroup conflict and introduces an innovative method for performing nuanced, cross-societal research.

God Values the Lives of My Out-Group More Than I Do: Evidence From Fiji and Israel

“…A half century of research suggests that certain aspects of religion (e.g., fundamentalism, coalitional motives) promote intergroup intolerance, whereas others (e.g., intrinsic belief, value signaling) promote intergroup tolerance (e.g., Allport & Ross, 1967;Altemeyer & Hunsberger, 2005;Everett et al, 2016;Ginges et al, 2009;Hall et al, 2015;Hunsberger & Jackson, 2005;M. K. Johnson et al, 2012;Neuberg et al, 2014).…”

Can identification as Muslim increase support for reconciliation? The case of the Kurdish conflict in Turkey

“…In today's world, most countries are composed of different ethnic, racial or religious groups between whom there is often a history of intergroup conflict or a potential for it (Neuberg et al, 2014). Intergroup conflicts not only affect those countries devastated by prolonged (armed) conflict between different groups but also more developed countries, for instance, with forced migration of refugees.…”

“…Research shows the widespread prejudice against Muslims (e.g., Awan & Zempi, 2016;Hutchison & Rosenthal, 2011;Wirtz, van der Pligt, & Doosje, 2016) and how Muslims and Muslim identity are problematized in Europe (Blackwood, Hopkins, & Reicher, 2013). Moreover, religious identification is generally associated with prejudice towards other groups (Scheepers, Gijsberts, & Hello, 2002), and religion associated with conflicts (Neuberg et al, 2014). However, Kunst and Thomsen (2015) show that religion can also create a common in-group.…”

Reconciliation and intergroup forgiveness: the case of the Kurdish conflict in Turkey

“…In today's world, most countries are plural societies, in the sense that they are composed of different ethnic, racial or religious groups. From a social and political psychology perspective, most conflicts arise from intergroup tensions in such plural societies 1 .…”