Reopening Schools during the COVID-19 Pandemic: Overview and Rapid Systematic Review of Guidelines and Recommendations on Preventive Measures and the Management of Cases

Abstract

Given the limited evidence of school closure effectiveness in containing the pandemic and the consequences for young people, reopening schools with appropriate measures is essential. This overview aimed to describe the main measures planned for the 2020–2021 academic year within the WHO European Region. A rapid systematic review of scientific databases was also performed. The websites of the government, Ministry of Health, and Ministry of Education of European Region countries were searched through 1 October for official documents about the prevention and management of suspected cases/confirmed cases in primary and secondary schools. To find further suggestions, a rapid systematic review was conducted through 20 October searching Pubmed, Scopus, and Embase. There were 23 official documents. France, Luxembourg, Malta, Ireland, Italy, Portugal, the UK, Spain, and San Marino were considered. Performing the rapid review, 855 records were identified and 7 papers were finally selected. The recommendations mostly agreed. However, there was no consensus on the criteria for the return to school of students that tested positive, and the flexibility between attendance at school and remote education for high-risk children often varied. School closure was commonly considered as the very last resort for COVID-19 control. Studies are required to evaluate the impact of different recommendations during this autumn term.

Impact of COVID-19 Home Confinement in Children’s Refractive Errors

“…From May 22, children were able to go outside without time limitations. In September 2020, face-to-face educational activity was resumed, adopting a series of prevention, hygiene, and health promotion measures against COVID-19 [ 16 ].…”

Fall 2020 COVID-19 Needs Assessment among New Jersey Secondary School Educational Professionals

“…Findings hold a potential implication to inform both the governance decisions and specific measures taken in updated school re-opening procedures for future emergencies, natural disasters, and infectious disease outbreaks. Indeed, a recent literature review conducted in the European Region of the World Health Organization reported both a lack of government documents and data on policy consensus for schools among high-risk vulnerable sub-populations, as well as for after positive test results [ 44 ]. Future research should focus on both the physical S&H of students and HS educational professionals, as well as their mental health.…”

La suspensión de la presencialidad escolar: un resumen de la evidencia disponible a nivel internacional respecto de su efectividad para contener la actual pandemia de COVID-19

“…El cierre de escuelas fue considerado generalmente como el último recurso para el control de la COVID-19. Las recomendaciones sobre el cierre escolar coincidían en su mayoría en que esta medida debía ser el último recurso para el control de la pandemia, no así en los criterios para el regreso a la escuela de los estudiantes que dieron positivo y la flexibilidad entre la asistencia a la escuela y la educación remota para los niños de alto riesgo 35 . La Organización Panamericana de la Salud (OPS) publicó una guía que analizó las consecuencias sanitarias, sociales y económicas de las medidas tomadas para el control de la pandemia relacionadas con el cierre de escuelas, así como los elementos que deben tenerse en cuenta a la hora de reabrirlas, con un enfoque en la niñez y la adolescencia en situaciones de vulnerabilidad.…”