Reporting of offspring data in diabetes, HIV infection and hypertension trials during pregnancy: a systematic review

Abstract

BackgroundClinical trials are conducted during pregnancy to evaluate benefits and risks of medicines for mother and child. The safety of maternal treatments is a key issue for healthcare professionals and parents.ObjectiveTo analyse offspring data reported in clinical trials in pregnant women with diabetes, HIV infection or hypertension (three of the most common diseases in women of childbearing potential) and either treated prior to pregnancy for these chronic diseases or diagnosed and treated during pregnancy.MethodsPubMed and Embase (1 January 1997 to 31 December 2017) were searched for drug trials in pregnant women with diabetes, HIV infection or hypertension. Titles and abstracts were screened, followed by a full-text review of eligible articles. Inclusion criteria were interventional clinical trials in pregnant women treated with medication and full text in English. Trial characteristics, maternal and offspring data were extracted. Data were summarised by disease and study. Twelve key items were considered for the offspring.ResultsOverall, 196 articles reporting 132 clinical trials (diabetes n=55; HIV n=59; hypertension n=18) were included. Key offspring data were frequently not reported, for example, number of births (diabetes: 22/55, 40%; HIV: 14/59, 24%; hypertension: 10/18, 56%). Congenital malformations were often not reported with sufficient detail (diabetes: 40/55, 73%; HIV: 39/59, 66%; hypertension: 17/18, 94%). Similar observations were made for other key items (eg, fetal losses, neonatal deaths).ConclusionUnder-reporting of key data for the offspring was frequent in publications of clinical trials in pregnant women with diabetes, HIV infection or hypertension making the assessment of the benefit-risk ratio of treatment options during pregnancy difficult.Trial registration numberCRD42017057024.

It is the time to change the paradigms of pregnant and breastfeeding women in clinical research!

“…This is the exact opposite of what happens because the outcomes of pregnancy were often not investigated and reported consistently. A recent systematic review found that clinical trials in pregnant women with diabetes, HIV infection, and hypertension did not report or only partially reported many essential offspring data (Aurich et al, 2020). Specifically, the number of births was frequently not reported, while congenital malformations, fetal losses, and neonatal deaths were often not reported with enough detail.…”