Representation of women on editorial boards of ophthalmology journals: protocol for a cross-sectional study

Abstract

IntroductionThere is a notable under-representation of women in leadership positions in ophthalmology despite the increasing number of women as ophthalmologists. Gender inequality in editorial boards of ophthalmology journals has not been investigated on a global scale. This study will aim to evaluate the representation of women as editorial board members in ophthalmology journals across different regions, journal subspecialties and impact factors.Methods and analysisThis will be a cross-sectional study describing the gender composition of editorial boards in ophthalmology journals globally. Ulrich’s Periodicals Directory and SCImago Journal & Country Rank will be used to comprehensively identify journals indexed with the keyword, ‘ophthalmology’. All journals with active websites and lists of editorial boards will be included. Journals will be categorised according to the World Bank’s 2021 classification of countries by income and region, and classified into ophthalmology subspecialties based on publication scope. Impact factors will be obtained from Journal Citation Reports. The gender and academic degrees of each editorial board member will be determined based on journal profiles, institutional websites or name query feature on an online interface. The research impact of each editorial board member will be ascertained from the author records on Web of Science. The gender proportion will be presented for all journals combined, and then for journals grouped by regions, subspecialties and impact factors. Editorial board member characteristics including academic degrees and research productivity measures will be compared between men and women. These comparisons will be made using the χ2 test for categorical variables and the independent samples t-test for continuous variables.Ethics and disseminationThis study did not require research ethics approval given the use of publicly available data and lack of human subjects. The results will be presented at scientific meetings and published in peer-reviewed journals.

Representation of women in ophthalmology journal editorial boards

“…Detailed methodologies including statistical analysis have been outlined in a previously published protocol of this study. 5 …”

“…Detailed methodologies including statistical analysis have been outlined in a previously published protocol of this study. 5 A total of 222 EiCs from 193 journals online supplemental eTable 1 as well as 2658 editors and 206 advisory board members from 55 journals listed on JCR were included. A detailed list of all of the included journals and their characteristics is included in the online supplemental eTable 1.…”

“…The Web of Science database was accessed in December 2021 to obtain data on each board member’s publication productivity measures. Detailed methodologies including statistical analysis have been outlined in a previously published protocol of this study 5…”