Research Landscape of Adaptive Learning in Education: A Bibliometric Study on Research Publications from 2000 to 2022

Abstract

Adaptive learning is an approach toward personalized learning and places the concept of “learner-centered education” into practice. With the rapid development of artificial intelligence and other technologies in recent years, there have been many breakthroughs in adaptive learning. Thus, it is important to gain insight into the evolution of related research and to track the research frontiers to further promote its development. This study used CiteSpace and VOSviewer to conduct a bibliometric analysis of 644 adaptive learning journal papers indexed in the WoS database from 2000 to 2022. This study presented a general view of the field of adaptive learning research over the last two decades using quantitative analysis. Currently, adaptive learning research is rapidly developing. In terms of the major research forces, a core group of authors including Qiao J. F., Han H. G. and Song Q has been formed; the major publishing country in this field is China; the core publishing journals include IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks and Learning Systems. Four major research topics in this field were identified using cluster analysis, namely the application of deep learning in educational data analysis, the development and application of adaptive learning model in AI education, the development and application of intelligent tutoring system in tutoring and teaching, cutting-edge modeling technology for feature modeling and knowledge tracing. Through evolution analyses, the logic of adaptive learning research’s development was determined; that is, technological changes have played a key role in the development of this field. Following the logic, we presented three frontiers of adaptive learning with burst terms: feature extraction, adaptation model and computational modeling. Adaptive learning is a core research topic for both computer science and educational technology disciplines, and it is also an important field where emerging technologies empowering education and teaching can play a part. The findings of the study clearly presented the current research status, evolutionary logic and research frontiers of this topic, which can provide references for the further development of this research field.

Research Hotspots and Development Trends of Education Digital Transformation: A Bibliometric Study

“…Timezone maps drawn using CiteSpace are used to depict the changes in the development frontiers and hotspots over time and to determine the focus of research frontiers in specific periods. In educational research, bibliometric research based on CiteSpace and VOSviewer has demonstrated its unique advantages and application value [7][8][9].…”

A bibliometric analysis of studies on technology‐supported learning environments: Hot topics and frontier evolution

“…Key initiatives in this direction include the development of adaptive learning platforms tailored to individual learning styles and pace, as discussed by Jing et al (2023) and Minn (2022), and social learning tools that encourage peer interaction and support, as noted by Barrot (2022). Additionally, acknowledging and accommodating cultural and educational background differences is crucial in adopting a “student‐learning” centric approach.…”

Global Trends in Preschool Literacy (PL) Based on Bibliometric Analysis: Progress and Prospects

“…Bubbles such as child, literacy, study, skill, and teacher are more prominent in Figure 8. Larger or darker bubbles usually indicate more important or frequently occurring keywords [77]; this allows researchers to understand that these terms have a higher level of interest in the literature.…”