Research trends in human resource management. A text-mining-based literature review

Abstract

PurposeThe purpose of the study was to detect trends in human resource management (HRM) research presented in journals during the 2000–2020 timeframe. The research question is: How are the interests of researchers changing in the field of HRM and which topics have gained popularity in recent years?Design/methodology/approachThe approach adopted in this study was designed to overcome all the limitations specific to the systematic literature reviews and bibliometric studies presented in the Introduction. The full texts of papers were analyzed. The text-mining tools detected first clusters and then trends, moreover, which limited the impact of a researcher's bias. The approach applied is consistent with the general rules of systematic literature reviews.FindingsThe article makes a threefold contribution to academic knowledge. First, it uses modern methodology to gather and synthesize HRM research topics. The proposed approach was designed to allow early detection of nascent, non-obvious trends in research, which will help researchers address topics of high value for both theory and practice. Second, the results of our study highlight shifts in focus in HRM over the past 19 years. Third, the article suggests further directions of research.Research limitations/implicationsIn this study, the approach designed to overcome the limitations of using systematic literature review was presented. The analysis was done on the basis of the full text of the articles and the categories were discovered directly from the articles rather than predetermined. The study's findings may, however, potentially be limited by the following issues. First, the eligibility criteria included only papers indexed in the Scopus and WoS database and excluded conference proceedings, book chapters, and non-English papers. Second, only full-text articles were included in the study, which could narrow down the research area. As a consequence, important information regarding the research presented in the excluded documents is potentially lost. Third, most of the papers in our database were published in the International Journal of Human Resource Management, and therefore such trends as “challenges for international HRM” can be considered significant (long-lasting). Another – the fourth – limitation of the study is the lack of estimation of the proportion between searches in HRM journals and articles published in other journals. Future research may overcome the above-presented limitations. Although the authors used valuable techniques such as TF-IDF and HDBSCAN, the fifth limitation is that, after trends were discovered, it was necessary to evaluate and interpret them. That could have induced researchers' bias even if – as in this study – researchers from different areas of experience were involved. Finally, this study covers the 2000–2020 timeframe. Since HRM is a rapidly developing field, in a few years from now academics will probably begin to move into exciting new research areas. As a consequence, it might be worthwhile conducting similar analyses to those presented in this study and compare their results.Originality/valueThe present study provides an analysis of HRM journals with the aim of establishing trends in HRM research. It makes contributions to the field by providing a more comprehensive and objective review than analyses resulting from systematic literature reviews. It fills the gap in literature studies on HRM with a novel research approach – a methodology based on full-text mining and a big data toolset. As a consequence, this study can be considered as providing an adequate reflection of all the articles published in journals strictly devoted to HRM issues and which may serve as an important source of reference for both researchers and practitioners. This study can help them identify the core journals focused on HRM research as well as topics which are of particular interest and importance.

Discovering knowledge map and evolutionary path of HRM and ER: using the STM combined with Word2vec

“…These approaches generally rely on subjective thoughts to produce results, which are static and difficult to be analyzed in depth. The consideration of keywords as research topics overcomes the shortcomings arising from subjectivity, which has been upheld in works such as Santana and Lopez-Cabrales (2019) and Piwowar-Sulej et al (2023). The latter places emphasis on text mining, which mines knowledge from richer academic texts.…”

Antecedents of Human Resource Information System Adoption: A Qualitative Study in French Context

“…The evolution of HRIS is associated with two factors: on the one hand, ICT disruptions, and the other hand, the evolution of HR management practices in companies (Piwowar-Sulej et al, 2022). Thus, an HRIS will merge the core activities and processes of Human Resource Management with the field of information technology (Shahreki, 2019).…”

“…Human resources management has become increasingly complex over the years, not least because of growing trends toward teleworking and globalization. HRIS evolutions have combined to move in four main directions, paving the way for the future of HR management (Piwowar-Sulej et al, 2022). In recruitment, the integration of AI can facilitate the recruitment process.…”

A Systematic Review: How Does Organisational Learning Enable ESG Performance (from 2001 to 2021)?

“…Up to now, with a focus on supporting green and low-carbon development in the fields of energy saving, environmental protection, and clean energy, more and more governments, financial institutions, and individual investors have begun to scrutinise companies' ESG performance [15]. Particularly, some scholars have highlighted the trend of green and sustainable human resource management, which shall be taken into consideration in future ESG strategies [16]. Therefore, it is urgent to design ESG training programs for practitioners in the human resource department [17].…”