IntroductionPlant diversity and soil chemical properties are important factors affecting the plant growth. We sought to compare the explanatory rates of diversity and soil chemical properties in explaining the variation of basal area in karst forests, and also sought to compare the relative importance of the niche complementarity and mass ratio hypotheses.MethodsOn the basis of linear regression and structural equation modelling, we examined the correlation between the basal area of plant communities and species diversity, functional diversity, phylogenetic diversity, the community-weighted mean (CWM) of traits, and soil chemical properties, using data obtained from 35 monitoring plots in southwest China.ResultsSpecies, functional, and phylogenetic diversities were all significantly correlated with the basal area of the plant community, among the indices of which, Faith’s phylogenetic diversity was found to have the greatest explanatory power for basal area. These plant diversity indices can better explain the variation in basal area than the CWM of traits, suggesting the niche complementarity hypothesis is more applicable than the mass ratio hypothesis. Moreover, soil chemical properties also have an equal important impact. Different chemical properties were found to show significant positive correlations with basal area, and their total effects on basal area were shown to be greater than the CWM of traits.DiscussionAttention should be paid to diversity and soil chemical properties. This study provides theoretical guidance for understanding biodiversity maintenance mechanisms and protecting karst forests.