Small impoundments (hereafter, "lakes") provide close-to-home fishing opportunities for many anglers but do not always provide quality fishing, especially for panfish. Often, these lakes contain populations of slow-growing Bluegill Lepomis macrochirus and crappies Pomoxis spp. The presence of abundant Gizzard Shad Dorosoma cepedianum and Common Carp Cyprinus carpio is known to negatively influence these populations. Chemical and mechanical removal of these nuisance species requires intensive effort, is costly, and usually results in only short-term benefits. An alternative approach is to stock piscivores that prey on these species and reduce their abundances. Hybrid Striped Bass (Striped Bass Morone saxatilis × White Bass Morone chrysops) alone or in combination with Flathead Catfish Pylodictis olivaris were stocked into small lakes to consume Gizzard Shad and Common Carp. To evaluate the success of this approach, I determined whether stockings of hybrid Striped Bass and Flathead Catfish were (1) associated with a consequent reduction in abundances and changes in size structure of Common Carp and Gizzard Shad, (2) related to improved growth rates and size structure of Bluegill and crappie populations, and (3) associated with changes in Largemouth Bass Micropterus salmoides demographics and aquatic macrophyte coverage. Nine treatment lakes were each paired with a reference lake, and fish population variables and macrophyte coverage were analyzed with a before-after, control-impact design. With a few exceptions, additions of piscivores were largely unsuccessful in reducing Gizzard Shad and Common Carp abundances and in improving growth of panfishes and the additions had little effect on Largemouth Bass or macrophyte coverage. A multi-pronged approach combining several methods (e.g., stocking of piscivores, reducing nutrients, and mechanical or chemical removal) may be necessary to effectively reduce the abundances of Gizzard Shad and Common Carp in these small lakes.