Responses to Thanks in Ireland, England and Canada: A Variational Pragmatic Perspective

Abstract

The present study investigates responses to thanks across the varieties of Irish English, English English and Canadian English. Data are taken from the Lueneburg Direction-Giving (LuDiG) corpus, a specialised corpus of spoken direction-giving exchanges across pluricentric varieties constructed using Labovian-style methods. The analysis centres on the cross-varietal pragmatic choices made in responding to thanks on the level of tokens, types and strategies. Findings point to the broad universality of realisations of responses to thanks across the pluricentric varieties at hand. Variety-preferential choices are, however, also recorded on a national level, particularly in type and strategy preferences. While all varieties use a ‘minimising the favour’ strategy extensively, this strategy is employed to a comparatively higher degree in the Irish English and English English data. In contrast, the speakers of Canadian English use an ‘expressing appreciation of the addressee’ strategy to a comparatively larger extent. Speakers of Canadian English are suggested to orient more strongly to positive face needs, and speakers of Irish English and English English more strongly towards negative face needs. The paper also discusses the methodological challenges of contrasting spoken interactional data for cross-varietal pragmatic speech act analyses and shows some strengths of specialised corpora in this regard.

How do Alexandrians and Najdis Apologize? A Variational Pragmatic Study of Arabic

“…However, the emergence of variational pragmatics (VP), which endorses the examination of intralingual variations in dialects that span within and across nations (e.g., British English, American English, Australian English; French French, Canadian French, Cameroon French) has transformed our perspective to languages and highlighted their pluricentric nature. Thus, VP has attracted the attention of several scholars from around the world (e.g., Barron, 2017Barron, , 2022El-Dakhs & Ahmed, 2021;Farenkia, 2011;Lochtman, 2022;Ren, 2015;Su & Chang, 2019;Yang & Deng, 2020;Yujie, 2021).…”