We are looking for probes for delineating the mechanism of bimolecular nucleophilic vinylic substitution proceeding by an initial nucleophilic attack on the double bond (the "addition-elimination" route). 1 With mildly activated systems the stronger evidence for a multistep route via an intermediate carbanion (eq 1) (i.e., A being an intermediate and not a transition state) is the element effect (the relative rates k when X ) F, Cl, Br, e.g., k Br / k Cl ), 2 which is not always available.-Halocinnamates belong to this class of compounds. Methyl -chlorocinnamates (ArC(Cl))CHCO 2 Me, Ar ) Ph, p-ClC 6 H 4 , p-Tol) undergo elimination with MeO -/ MeOH, 3a-c but with PhS -, substitution takes place, giving the retained substitution product. 3d This and the formation of the isomeric E/Z substitution products in the addition of PhS -/H + to the corresponding methyl propiolates (ArCtCCO 2 Me) exclude an elimination-addition route, except when Ar ) p-O 2 NC 6 H 4 when the substitution gives E/Z substitution products mixture.Adams and co-workers have prepared and resolved to enantiomers two pairs of -chlorocinnamic acids: the R-Me 4a and R-H 4b with 3-bromo-2,4,6-trimethyl substituents; i.e., the aryl group is 3-bromomesityl. The optical activity results from hindered rotation around the Ar-Cdbond due to the steric interaction of the o-Me substituents with the double-bond substituents, which lead to atropisomerism. We reasoned that if a carbanion A with a finite lifetime is formed by attack on C giving a carbanion, the locked geometry may be relaxed, leading to a racemized product, whereas if the reaction is concerted (i.e., A is a transition state) this will not happen. Since the activation by a carboxyl is low and the negative charge on a carboxylate may complicate the study, the corresponding esters seem to be suitable substrates. Such an approach was applied by Cabaret, Welvart, and co-workers in a related system. 5 Two practical problems that may complicate the study are the possibility of a substitution via eliminationaddition and the possibility of a racemization of the precursor due to a low rotational barrier. Both problems are reduced with the R-Me compound ArC(Cl)dC(Me)-CO 2 Me (Ar ) 3-Br-2,4,6-Me 3 C 6 H) since the barrier in the acids is relatively high and there is no vinylic hydrogen available for elimination. 4a In a study of this ester, we found that dechlorocarbomethoxylation reaction with a loss of both the Cl and the CO 2 Me groups led to an acetylene and not to a substitution product. 6 This was apparently due to the excessive steric hindrance to approach to the vinylic carbon.Consequently, in the present work, we prepared the R-H analog. It is known that racemization of the acid takes place in n-BuOH with a half-life of 206 min at reflux. Moreover, the system is a priori prone to R,elimination. However, according to Adams, 4 the isomer studied is the E isomer where the hydrogen and chlorine are cis to one another so that E2 elimination may be difficult.The study of this system therefore imposes s...