Results and Guidelines From a Repeated-Measures Design Experiment Comparing Standing and Seated Full-Body Gesture-Based Immersive Virtual Reality Exergames: Within-Subjects Evaluation

Abstract

Background Although full-body seated exercises have been studied in a wide range of settings (ie, homes, hospitals, and daycare centers), they have rarely been converted to seated exergames. In addition, there is an increasing number of studies on immersive virtual reality (iVR) full-body gesture-based standing exergames, but the suitability and usefulness of seated exergames remain largely unexplored. Objective This study aimed to evaluate the difference between playing a full-body gesture-based iVR standing exergame and seated exergame in terms of gameplay performance, intrinsic motivation, and motion sickness. Methods A total of 52 participants completed the experiment. The order of the game mode (standing and sitting) was counterbalanced. Gameplay performance was evaluated by action or gesture completion time and the number of missed gestures. Exertion was measured by the average heart rate (HR) percentage (AvgHR%), increased HR%, calories burned, and the Borg 6-20 questionnaire. Intrinsic motivation was assessed with the Intrinsic Motivation Inventory (IMI), whereas motion sickness was assessed via the Motion Sickness Assessment Questionnaire (MSAQ). In addition, we measured the fear of falling using a 10-point Likert scale questionnaire. Results Players missed more gestures in the seated exergame than in the standing exergame, but the overall miss rate was low (2.3/120, 1.9%). The analysis yielded significantly higher AvgHR%, increased HR%, calories burned, and Borg 6-20 rating of perceived exertion values for the seated exergame (all P<.001). The seated exergame was rated significantly higher on peripheral sickness (P=.02) and sopite-related sickness (MSAQ) (P=.004) than the standing exergame. The score of the subscale “value/usefulness” from IMI was reported to be higher for the seated exergame than the standing exergame. There was no significant difference between the seated exergame and standing exergame in terms of intrinsic motivation (interest/enjoyment, P=.96; perceived competence, P=.26; pressure/tension, P=.42) and the fear of falling (P=.25). Conclusions Seated iVR full-body gesture-based exergames can be valuable complements to standing exergames. Seated exergames have the potential to lead to higher exertion, provide higher value to players, and be more applicable in small spaces compared with standing exergames. However, gestures for seated exergames need to be designed carefully to minimize motion sickness, and more time should be given to users to perform gestures in seated exergames compared with standing exergames.

Enabling Immersive Exercise Activities for Older Adults: A Comparison of Virtual Reality Exergames and Traditional Video Exercises

“…Four people (P 1 -P 4 , all female, average age: 81.75 ± 4.19 years) participated in a pre-study to determine a suitable length and difficulty for the game. We planned to play the game in a standing position, but two of the (first-time VR) users asked to sit down after putting on the head-mounted display (HMD) because they felt insecure, and sitting exergames can also provide a high usefulness to players [55], so we chose this setup for all following players.…”

Embodiment in Virtual Reality Intensifies Emotional Responses to Virtual Stimuli

“…Previous investigations demonstrated the applicability of the sensation of embodiment in different virtual reality applications, such as health (Ramakonar et al, 2011 ; Martini, 2016 ; Matamala-Gomez et al, 2019 , 2021 ) and entertainment (Riva et al, 2016 ; Slater and Sanchez-Vives, 2016 ; Xu et al, 2020 ). However, we know little about the mechanisms of how virtual embodiment affects the effectiveness of such applications.…”

vrCAPTCHA: Exploring CAPTCHA Designs in Virtual Reality

“…3.3)). This motionbased CAPTCHA is inspired by previous exergame research studies [1,9,13,17,18] which demonstrate the immersion that upper body limb movements can bring in VR. It is engaging for users to follow the virtual character and move their bodies.…”