Results of a qualitative study of patient, carer and clinician views on the experience of caring for individuals with psychosis in Pakistan

Abstract

Cultural relevance is a core element of effective psychological interventions like cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) or family intervention (FI), which can be considered Eurocentric. There have been few studies that have examined explanatory models of mental illness and its management in Pakistan to date. This study elicited patient- and carer-related health beliefs on psychosis including attributions to illness, and help-seeking behaviours to inform development of culturally sensitive treatment and improve outcomes in a unit in Lahore (Pakistan). The study group completed 45 semi-structured qualitative interviews at a mental health rehabilitation centre in Lahore. Data were analysed thematically using emerging themes and content analysis. Participants’ explanatory models for psychosis included religion or faith-driven beliefs, like previous wrong-doing and supernatural ideas such as black magic. Social factors that impacted families included high expectations, social stigma, and discriminations. Families first sought help from faith leaders and then medical or psychological sources of care. Participants had generally positive attitudes about their experience of psychological interventions. Key learning aims (1) The need to consider cultural influences to ensure relevance of interventions like cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) or family interventions (FI) in different countries. (2) The need for cultural adaptation of interventions like CBT and FI in different countries to make them accessible and acceptable. (3) When adapting therapy to a particular culture or country, recognizing the importance of engaging the local cultural population in the adaptation process.

Belief in Jinn Possession Scale: Development and validation

“…Cultural diversity is present in understanding mental health and the issues related to it globally, but, unfortunately, the dangers of applying Western explanatory models to the experiences of different cultural groups, without an acknowledgment of cultural differences, are obvious (Apers et al, 2023). One of the most commonly encountered cultural explanatory frameworks comprises of faith-driven supernatural explanatory models (Jacobi et al, 2022;Pan et al, 2020;Rathod et al, 2023) that are more resilient one in society than other models. Understanding these indigenous knowledge systems is important because culturally specific notions about mental health may determine how people seek out medical care (Martinez et al, 2020), respond to disease, and the implementation of effective approaches to mental health care (Arundell et al, 2020).…”