Retail robots as sales assistants: how speciesism moderates the effect of robot intelligence on customer perceptions and behaviour

Abstract

PurposeRetailers increasingly endeavour to implement artificial intelligence (AI) innovations, such as humanoid social robots (HSRs), to enhance customer experience. This paper investigates the interactive effect of HSR intelligence and consumers' speciesism on their perceptions of retail robots as sales assistants.Design/methodology/approachThree online experiments testing the effects of HSRs' intellectual intelligence on individuals' perceived competence and, consequently, their decision to shop at a retail store that uses HSRs as sales assistants are reported. Furthermore, the authors examine whether speciesism attenuates these effects such that a mediation effect is likely to be observed for individuals low in speciesism but not for those with high levels of speciesism. Data for all studies were collected on Prolific and analysed with SPSS to perform a logistic regression and PROCESS 4.0 (Hayes, 2022) for the mediation and moderated-mediation analysis.FindingsThe findings show that the level of speciesism moderates the relationship between HSR intellectual intelligence and perceived competence such that an effect is found for low but not for high HSR intelligence. When HSR intellectual intelligence is low, individuals with higher levels of speciesism (vs low) rate the HSR as less competent and display lower HSR acceptance (i.e. customers' decision to shop using retail robots as sales assistants).Originality/valueThis research responds to calls in research to adopt a human-like perspective to understand the compatibility between humans and robots and determine how personality traits, such as a person's level of speciesism, may affect the acceptance of AI technologies replicating human characteristics (Schmitt, 2019). To the best of the authors' knowledge, the present research is the first to examine the moderating role of speciesism on customer perceptions of non-human retail assistants (i.e. human-like and intelligent service robots). This study is the first to showcase that speciesism, normally considered a negative social behaviour, can positively influence individuals' decisions to engage with HSRs.

Guest editorial: Collaborating and sharing with AI: a research agenda

“…Fiestas Lopez Guido et al . 's manuscript (2024) titled “Retail Robots as Sales Assistants: How Speciesism Moderates the Effect of Robot Intelligence on Customer Perceptions and Behaviour” conducts a series of experiments to examine how the interaction between a humanoid social robot's intelligence and perceived speciesism (a human personality trait representing discrimination or prejudice against non-human species) influences perceived competence and purchase likelihood. Individuals with high levels of speciesism are less inclined to collaborate with AI, particularly when they perceive the AI as having lower intellectual intelligence.…”