Review and Evaluation of Mindfulness-Based iPhone Apps

Abstract

BackgroundThere is growing evidence for the positive impact of mindfulness on wellbeing. Mindfulness-based mobile apps may have potential as an alternative delivery medium for training. While there are hundreds of such apps, there is little information on their quality.ObjectiveThis study aimed to conduct a systematic review of mindfulness-based iPhone mobile apps and to evaluate their quality using a recently-developed expert rating scale, the Mobile Application Rating Scale (MARS). It also aimed to describe features of selected high-quality mindfulness apps.MethodsA search for “mindfulness” was conducted in iTunes and Google Apps Marketplace. Apps that provided mindfulness training and education were included. Those containing only reminders, timers or guided meditation tracks were excluded. An expert rater reviewed and rated app quality using the MARS engagement, functionality, visual aesthetics, information quality and subjective quality subscales. A second rater provided MARS ratings on 30% of the apps for inter-rater reliability purposes.ResultsThe “mindfulness” search identified 700 apps. However, 94 were duplicates, 6 were not accessible and 40 were not in English. Of the remaining 560, 23 apps met inclusion criteria and were reviewed. The median MARS score was 3.2 (out of 5.0), which exceeded the minimum acceptable score (3.0). The Headspace app had the highest average score (4.0), followed by Smiling Mind (3.7), iMindfulness (3.5) and Mindfulness Daily (3.5). There was a high level of inter-rater reliability between the two MARS raters.ConclusionsThough many apps claim to be mindfulness-related, most were guided meditation apps, timers, or reminders. Very few had high ratings on the MARS subscales of visual aesthetics, engagement, functionality or information quality. Little evidence is available on the efficacy of the apps in developing mindfulness.

Mobile Apps for Management of Tinnitus: Users’ Survey, Quality Assessment, and Content Analysis (Preprint)

“…The Functionality scale had a highest median score, with questions about performance, ease of use, navigation and gestural design. This is in line with the results of previous studies using MARS for quality assessment of weight management apps [18], prevention of driving after drinking alcohol apps [19], and mindfulness-based apps [20] where functionality scores were also the highest.…”

Mindfulness as substitute for transformational leadership

“…Even simple and short interventions focusing on meditation techniques in work contexts (Hülsheger et al, 2013(Hülsheger et al, , 2015 or short web-based programs that combine live, weekly hour-long virtual classes with accompanying online applied training have shown promising results (Aikens et al, 2014). Mindfulness-based mobile apps may have potential as an alternative delivery medium for training (Mani et al, 2015). These simple interventions, which come at affordable expenses, may therefore play an important role in bolstering employee resilience and self-management.…”

Formative evaluation on cultural tailoring breathing awareness meditation smartphone apps to reduce stress and blood pressure

“…Very little evidence is available on the efficacy of other meditation/BAM apps in developing effective habits and mindfulness, and none have documented outcomes on BP besides TT (38). Initially, pre-essential hypertension (preEH) and EH youth and adults guided the structure and refinement of early TT app content and presentation through focus groups [e.g., TT app consists of a brief overview communicated via cartoon and text, FAQ, audio and text based BAM instructions, heart rate (HR) feedback graphs, etc.].…”