“…In economics, for example, bibliometric studies can be seen in Laila et al (2021) Other examples of studies with bibliometric methods include studies in the fields of accounting (Taqi et al, 2021;Rusydiana et al, 2020;Taqi et al, 2022;, finance As-salafiyah et al, 2022;Maulida, 2023), marketing (Rusydiana et al, 2023;Uula & Avedta, 2023;Putri & Irfany, 2023;Sari & Maysyaroh, 2022) Islamic economics (Marlina et al, 2021;Rusydiana, 2021;Sukmana et al, 2021;Nuraini, 2022), social finance (Nuraini, 2021;Niswah, 2022) to studies related to the halal industry (Izza, 2021;Nekha & Kartikawati, 2022;Rahardjo, 2023;. The most widely used tools in bibliometric studies are VosViewer (Uula & Ikhwan, 2022;Avedta, 2023;Sanrego & Taufiq, 2023;Riani, 2021) and the Biblioshiny-R application (Gunawan & Herman, 2022;Nuraini & Jazil, 2023;Puspita et al, 2023;Ikhwan, 2021).…”