Review Papers Examining accountability in relation to local football communities

Abstract

PurposeMost football clubs were founded by members of the local community within which they are based. The success of a club is built on the time, effort and resources given by these locals, which is offered due to the benefits that football promises to the community in return. However, the game has increasingly been dominated by a focus on financial (monetary) value, at the expense of such benefits being delivered to the clubs' local communities. This article examines a need for deliberation over what accountability is owed by football clubs to their local communities in the context of questioning what and for whom football is for.Design/methodology/approachThis exploration is undertaken within the context of the English game, where a series of issues has resulted in the UK Government undertaking a “fan led review of football governance”. The report produced by this review is analysed to understand whether the contents and recommendations enters the debate over what accountability is owed to local communities.FindingsWhile the UK Government's fan led review recognises the pivotal role of local communities in the formation of the English game, its focus and resulting recommendations are mostly on the financial sustainability of the clubs. The analysis demonstrates that, due to their focus on financial value, the implementation of the report's recommendations is more likely to exacerbate the underlying issues rather than resolving them.Originality/valueThe call for deliberation over whether and what accountability is owed to local communities has been repeated over time. The UK Government's fan led review provided an important opportunity to engage in that deliberation. However, the dominance of financial value within football has all but silenced any call for and action regarding this.

Exploring a Soccer Society: dreams, themes and the beautiful game

“…However, this is not necessarily the assumed prevalent consequence of changes in the modern game that often bring to the fore the dominant impact of financial resources. Burns and Jollands (2022), in recognising that, at the highest professional levels, the game has increasingly been influenced by a focus on financial value, even go as far as to suggest that government proposals to ensure accountability by soccer clubs to the local communities that house, support and embrace them may well meet substantial engrained obstacles. Indeed, in analysing one UK initiative to improve the situation, they argue that, due to its focus on financial value, the implementation of recommendations emanating from the consequent review process was more likely to exacerbate the underlying problem relating to a disconnect between a club and its community, rather than ameliorate it.…”