Cutaneous melanoma is the fifth leading cause of new cancer diagnoses, accounting for almost 77,000 cases and more than 9000 deaths in 2013. Although these cutaneous neoplasms are so common, their mucosal counterparts are much less so. Mucosal melanomas account for approximately only 1.3% of all diagnosed melanomas. These lesions, although rare, present at a significantly advanced stage with more adverse prognoses. In addition, molecularly, these lesions have proven to be distinct entities, in that they possess mutations not usually seen in their cutaneous counterparts. They also lack the common mutations found in cutaneous melanomas. Such findings indicate different pathways in tumorigenesis for these subtypes. We present a case of a mucosal melanoma, specifically a urethral melanoma, in a 70-year-old woman, clinically diagnosed as a urethral caruncle. Only after biopsy and resection was the correct diagnosis of malignant melanoma made. As melanomas arising from the mucosal sites are a rare entity, very little has been published on staging guidelines and prognostic factors, causing a dilemma for both the patient and the physician. Further work is necessary to better define a staging system in all mucosal locations, so that accurate prognoses can be given to patients with these lesions. Lastly, metastases from a more common cutaneous site must be considered.We present a case of a 70-year-old white woman who initially presented to her primary care physician with gross hematuria. She denied any additional signs and symptoms and was referred to a urologist for further evaluation. Upon urologic evaluation, a distal urethral mass was noted, presumed to be a benign urethral caruncle, and was scheduled for surgical excision. Histologic examination of the mass proved to be a surprise, however. The excisional biopsy consisted of fragments of squamous epithelial-lined tissue with an obvious cellular malignancy extending into the urethral submucosa. The malignant cells exhibited abundant eosinophilic cytoplasm, nuclear pleomorphism, nuclear hyperchromasia, and prominent nucleoli. Numerous mitotic figures and apoptotic bodies were noted, indicating a high proliferation rate. The malignant cells extended to both the deep and peripheral margins of the tissue. Multiple immunohistochemical stains were applied to determine the origin of these cells. The tumor cells proved to be negative for CD34 and smooth muscle actin. They also proved to be negative for TTF-1, cytokeratins 7 and 20, estrogen receptor, and high-molecular-weight cytokeratin, indicating that these cells were not of an epithelial origin. They did stain positively for melan-A and S-100, confirming a melanocytic lineage. Molecular studies were performed on the biopsy and were negative for a mutation in the BRAF and c-KIT genes.The patient then underwent a formal distal urethrectomy and staging procedure. Grossly, the specimen was covered by an intact mucosa and had a semifirm submucosal mass at one aspect. Upon sectioning the specimen, a soft, fleshy, well-circumscri...