Revised Approach to the Role of Fatigue in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury Prevention: A Systematic Review with Meta-Analyses

Abstract

BackgroundCauses of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries are multifactorial. Anterior cruciate ligament injury prevention should thus be approached from a multifactorial perspective as well. Training to resist fatigue is an underestimated aspect of prevention programs given that the presence of fatigue may play a crucial role in sustaining an ACL injury.ObjectivesThe primary objective of this literature review was to summarize research findings relating to the kinematic and kinetic effects of fatigue on single-leg landing tasks through a systematic review and meta-analysis. Other objectives were to critically appraise current approaches to examine the effects of fatigue together with elucidating and proposing an optimized approach for measuring the role of fatigue in ACL injury prevention.MethodsA systematic literature search was conducted in the databases PubMed (1978–November 2017), CINAHL (1992–November 2017), and EMBASE (1973–November 2017). The inclusion criteria were: (1) full text, (2) published in English, German, or Dutch, (3) healthy subjects, (4) average age ≥ 18 years, (5) single-leg jump landing task, (6) evaluation of the kinematics and/or kinetics of the lower extremities before and after a fatigue protocol, and (7) presentation of numerical kinematic and/or kinetic data. Participants included healthy subjects who underwent a fatigue protocol and in whom the effects of pre- and post-fatigue on three-dimensional lower extremity kinematic and kinetics were compared. Methods of data collection, patient selection, blinding, prevention of verification bias, and study design were independently assessed.ResultsTwenty studies were included, in which four types of single-leg tasks were examined: the single-leg drop vertical jump, the single-leg drop landing, the single-leg hop for distance, and sidestep cutting. Fatigue seemed to mostly affect initial contact (decreased angles post-fatigue) and peak (increased angles post-fatigue) hip and knee flexion. Sagittal plane variables at initial contact were mostly affected under the single-leg hop for distance and sidestep cutting conditions whilst peak angles were affected during the single-leg drop jump.ConclusionsTraining to resist fatigue is an underestimated aspect of prevention programs given that the presence of fatigue may play a crucial role in sustaining an ACL injury. Considering the small number of variables affected after fatigue, the question arises whether the same fatigue pathways are affected by the fatigue protocols used in the included laboratory studies as are experienced on the sports field.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1007/s40279-019-01052-6) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Effects of Two Competitive Soccer Matches on Landing Biomechanics in Female Division I Soccer Players

“…Numerous studies have tested the effects of a single actual or simulated soccer match on markers of physical performance, including repeated sprint ability, vertical jump, and maximum voluntary leg strength, and almost all have found consistent effects of fatigue lasting as long as 48–72 h post-match [8,9]. However, several recent reviews point out that the kinematic and kinetic risk factors for non-contact ACL injury are not consistently present after a single bout of fatiguing exercise [10,11,12].…”

Changes in Duration and Intensity of the World’s Top-Level Badminton Matches: A Consideration of the Increased Acute Injuries among Elite Women’s Singles Players

“…Therefore, especially in women's singles matches played between higher-ranked players, more attention should be paid in the preparation of the players to prevent injury. Benjaminse et al (2019) suggested that training to resist fatigue could be effective for injury prevention as fatigue may play a crucial role in sustaining an ACL injury [20].…”

The Influence of Exercise-Induced Fatigue on Inter-Limb Asymmetries: a Systematic Review

“…Their approach includes physiological and psychological processes, but fatigue is only regarded as a general phenomenon and not divided into subcategories, e.g., central or peripheral fatigue. Benjaminse et al [43] also describe fatigue as a complex interaction between psychological and physical factors. This interaction might influence the reactions to external stimuli and the decisions of an athlete in complex situations, e.g., landing or cutting in high-risk sports.…”