Rhetorical Move and Linguistic Features Comparative Analysis of Research Article Abstracts by Authors of Different Organizational Backgrounds

Kanafani, Ashifa; Nurcik, Ananta Buana; Harisbaya, Ayu Intan; Qurratu’aini, Syifa Fauzia; Kurniawan, Eri; Lubis, Arif Husein

doi:10.2991/assehr.k.211119.021

Cited by 4 publications

(4 citation statements)

References 10 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…Those findings were partly in line with some related previous studies (e.g. Harisbaya et al, 2021;Kanafani et al, 2021;Kurniawan et al, 2019). In Harisbaya et al 's findings, Move 4 became one of the prior moves, yet the appearance still did not predominate the data.…”

Section: Move-step Occurrencessupporting

confidence: 91%

Authors’ Affiliation Influence Towards Rhetorical Moves and Linguistic Features of Rejected Raas

Harisbaya

Kurniawan

Lubis

2023

ERJEE

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

An abstract is the selling point of a research article (RA), due to the fact that it can help the readers and particularly journal reviewers in selecting which RAs are remarkable to be read further and accepted. A plethora of research has analyzed the rhetorical moves and linguistic features of accepted RAAs. Nevertheless, almost none of them have explored the rejected one, based on the authors’ affiliation. Invoking Hyland’s (2000) rhetorical move model as the main instrument, this study intends to dismantle and fill up those lacunas by utilizing 31 rejected RAAs in total from Indonesian Journal of Applied Linguistics (IJAL), submitted in 2019, 2020, and 2021. The data were then separated into the same affiliation (13 abstracts) and different affiliation (18 abstracts) groups in order to find the commonality and discrepancy in the rhetorical move and linguistic features (i.e. tenses, voice, and grammatical subjects). As a result, the authors’ affiliation had some influences on the structure of rhetorical moves of RAAs and the accommodation of linguistic features in each move. It also appeared that there were some primary shortcomings found in the rejected abstracts as compared to the accepted ones. This study can be adopted as the reference for future research in rhetorical moves analysis, specifically regarding the authors’ affiliation and rejected RAAs.

show abstract

Section: Move-step Occurrencessupporting

confidence: 91%

Authors’ Affiliation Influence Towards Rhetorical Moves and Linguistic Features of Rejected Raas

Harisbaya

Kurniawan

Lubis

2023

ERJEE

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Hence, confirming that the high proportion of past tenses in Move 3 of both data groups and Move 4 of international authors' abstracts is in accordance with the typical characteristics of the moves. Voice-wise, the extensive use of active voice dominating the voice's proportion across all the moves resonates with the findings of Kanafani et al (2021), Gani et al (2020), Andika et al (2018), Harisbaya et al (2021), andKuniawan andSabila (2021).…”

Section: Linguistic Featuressupporting

confidence: 73%

Rhetorical Moves Analysis on Scopus-Indexed Research Article Abstracts by National and International Authors

Nurcik

Kurniawan

Lubis

2022

ERJEE

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Abstracts in research articles are important for readers in determining whether to continue reading the article or not. A plethora of studies involving abstracts’ rhetorical moves has previously been published, but scant attention has been given to the relationship between the rhetorical moves and authors’ nationalities. This study is aimed at comparing the rhetorical moves and linguistic realizations of abstracts by authors of different nationalities. This study analyzed 30 hard sciences abstracts written by national and international authors published in the International Journal of Science and Technology (IJoST). Hyland’s (2000) model of rhetorical moves was employed as the framework of analysis. Findings showed that both groups similarly spent more space in manifesting the method and findings moves. However significant differences were evident in the steps of the introduction and method moves. National authors considered the conclusion move as optional, whereas the other moves in both groups were considered conventional. International authors considered topic generalization step as conventional, while all other steps in the introduction move of both groups were optional. No difference was found in the voices used. However, tense-wise, the international authors favored present tenses in describing the research purpose while the national authors favored past tenses. This study concludes that the differences in the rhetorical organizations between the international and national authors can mostly be found in the steps, instead of the moves. Additionally, as the use of voice does not show any difference, the use of different tenses in each move distinguishes the two groups of authors.

show abstract

“…The correlation between language, culture, and nature is also decreasing, especially in understanding language-speaking people towards environmental diversity, manifested in a lexicon closely related to a particular environment (eco-lexicon). Vocabulary in a language can be represented as a complex inventory of all ideas, interests, and activities of a particular speech or ethnic group that reflects the characteristics of the physical and cultural environment of the community [7]. Furthermore, Renjaan (2014) claims that the ecolexicon reflects the cognitive intelligence of the speaker [8].…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Ecolexicon Social Praxis Dimensions in Mosehe Wonua’s Ritual

Mbete¹,

Umiyati²,

Nurwahyuni³

2023

Proceedings of the 2nd International Student Conference on Linguistics (ISCL 2022)

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The reasons for the emergence of ecolinguistics are, among others, a result of the progress of human ecology because of the interconnections and interdependencies between all types of systems (including economic systems, social systems, religious systems, cultural systems, linguistic systems, and ecosystems) which are continuously highlighted and explored. The research aims to describe ecolexicon social praxis dimensions in mosehe wonua's ritual. This study was designed with a qualitative approach. This approach was chosen because it can answer the problem formulation that has been formulated in the previous introduction. A qualitative approach is used to answer the problem formulation. The data of this research are written data taken from the published manuscripts of Tolaki oral literature. The result shows that the social praxis dimension of the Mosehe Wonua ritual mantra lexicon affects UDB in Poasia District. The biological dimension is demonstrated through the persistence of the proper reference of each lexicon. The ideological dimension refers to the lexicon used in the metaphor for the symbol of reference to the concept referred to in a situation. Finally, the sociological dimension is shown through the use of ritual lexicon in conveying a particular concept by speakers and listeners of UDB in the Poasia District. In this case, the mosehe wonua ritual needs to be preserved because it contains an eco-collection that represents the Tolaki-speaking Guyub culture so that the younger generation can know the philosophical meanings contained therein and provide an economic impact by realizing Kendari City as a tourist city.

show abstract

Rhetorical Move and Linguistic Features Comparative Analysis of Research Article Abstracts by Authors of Different Organizational Backgrounds

Cited by 4 publications

References 10 publications

Authors’ Affiliation Influence Towards Rhetorical Moves and Linguistic Features of Rejected Raas

Authors’ Affiliation Influence Towards Rhetorical Moves and Linguistic Features of Rejected Raas

Rhetorical Moves Analysis on Scopus-Indexed Research Article Abstracts by National and International Authors

Ecolexicon Social Praxis Dimensions in Mosehe Wonua’s Ritual

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About