Risk-Based Evaluation of Improvements in Drinking Water Treatment Using Cost-Benefit Analysis

Abstract

Reliable and safe drinking water supply requires adequate risk management. Decision support models can aid decisionmakers to effectively evaluate risk mitigation measures and allocate societal resources. Here, a Swedish case study illustrates how the installation of ultrafiltration membranes can be evaluated by combining risk assessment and cost-benefit analysis. Quantitative microbial risk assessment was used to assess several contamination sources and estimate the achieved risk reduction from waterborne pathogens using Campylobacter, Norovirus, and Cryptosporidium as reference pathogens. The societal value of the improved water quality was estimated in the cost-benefit analysis by monetising the gained quality adjusted life years and aesthetic water quality improvements. The calculated net present value (mean of 7 MEUR) indicated that the installation of the ultrafiltration membranes was a sound investment from a societal economic perspective. The ultrafiltration membranes reduced the annual probability of infection from 3 × 10−2 to 10−7, well below the U.S. EPA’s acceptable level, as well as improving the aesthetic quality of the drinking water. The results provide a novel example of the importance for water distributors to consider not only health-related metrics when evaluating treatment options or monitoring the drinking water quality, but to also consider the aesthetic quality of the drinking water.

Do the Health Benefits of Boiling Drinking Water Outweigh the Negative Impacts of Increased Indoor Air Pollution Exposure?

“…A cost benefit analysis on water treatment showed the benefits of the filters outweighed the costs only when including aesthetic benefits, not health benefits alone. 112 A cost-benefit analysis for a combined cookstove and water treatment intervention (an improved stove and water filter) in Rwanda showed that benefits from fuelwood savings, time savings, and environmental and health improvements outweighed the cost. 33 However, fuel savings among new water filter users were found only for households who previously boiled their water, not for households which had not treated their water previously.…”

Advanced Techniques for Monitoring and Management of Urban Water Infrastructures—An Overview

“…Another approach is presented in [170], combining QMRA and CBA to measure microbial health risks and socio-economic profitability. Moreover, in the process of drinking water treatment, the need for a holistic approach is emphasized.…”

An Optimal Maintenance and Replacement Strategy for Deteriorating Water Mains

“…Figure 3 shows 100 simulated TTS point processes starting from t 1 = 0. For the simulations, P s is randomly sampled from a uniform distribution of U ∼ [0, 1].…”

“…Water mains are key municipal infrastructure assets supporting the daily life of citizens [1]. Though water mains are designed to serve for several decades, they deteriorate with increasing service age, and can break before reaching the target design life.…”