We aim to review modifiable risk factors and practices for surgical site infections (SSIs) reduction in cutaneous surgeries. The existing norms are assessed with the latest evidence, with the aim of enhancing and optimizing intra and postoperative strategies. This review seeks to offer an updated summary of the results of evidence for SSI reduction strategies tailored for practicing general dermatologists. Searches were conducted for “cutaneous surgery surgical site infection complications” using PubMed Central® and DynaMed®. Articles with pragmatic guideline recommendations were selected. We found evidence for intraoperative factors such as non-sterile gloves, brushless hand scrubbing/simple hand washing, sterile materials, and chlorhexidine gluconate as a skin antiseptic. For postoperative factors, there is a lack of evidence to support the use of topical antibiotic ointments, dressings, or waiting 48 hours before wetting to prevent SSI. Several intra/postoperative factors not specific to dermatologic procedures are briefly discussed for additional context. Several SSI risk factors are inherent to patients or necessary procedures; however, dermatologists have identified modifiable risk factors and developed protocols to mitigate SSI risks intraoperatively and postoperatively. By questioning established practices in cutaneous surgery aimed at preventing SSIs, we can work towards the optimal utilization of resources. This dual-focused approach not only enhances the efficiency of the healthcare system but also diminishes the risks associated with SSIs. It is important to acknowledge that this review does not encompass all factors essential for consideration in these recommendations. Nonetheless, it will approach these factors with an evidence-based lens, placing SSI prevention at the forefront.