Risk prediction in the community: A systematic review of case-finding instruments that predict adverse healthcare outcomes in community-dwelling older adults

Abstract

Few case-finding instruments are available to community healthcare professionals. This review aims to identify short, valid instruments that detect older community-dwellers risk of four adverse outcomes: hospitalisation, functional-decline, institutionalisation and death. Data sources included PubMed and the Cochrane library. Data on outcome measures, patient and instrument characteristics, and trial quality (using the Quality In Prognosis Studies [QUIPS] tool), were double-extracted for derivation-validation studies in community-dwelling older adults (>50 years). Forty-six publications, representing 23 unique instruments, were included. Only five were externally validated. Mean patient age range was 64.2-84.6 years. Most instruments n=18, (78%) were derived in North America from secondary analysis of survey data. The majority n=12, (52%), measured more than one outcome with hospitalisation and the Probability of Repeated Admission score the most studied outcome and instrument respectively. All instruments incorporated multiple predictors. Activities of daily living n=16, (70%), was included most often. Accuracy varied according to instruments and outcomes; area under the curve of 0.60-0.73 for hospitalisation, 0.63-0.78 for functional decline, 0.70-0.74 for institutionalisation and 0.56-0.82 for death. The QUIPS tool showed that 5/23 instruments had low potential for bias across all domains. This review highlights the present need to develop short, reliable, valid instruments to case-find older adults at risk in the community.

Predicting Trajectories of Functional Decline in 60- to 70-Year-Old People

“…However, prior studies on understanding the course of functional decline have been performed in older populations with a majority of people well above 70 years of age, in whom functional decline was often already present [5]. By focusing on a younger cohort of older people, we will be better able to identify distinct subgroups in the population who may be target groups for preventive interventions.…”

Tackling frailty and functional decline: Background of the action group A3 of the European innovation partnership for active and healthy ageing

“…b) The CARTS (Community Assessment of Risk & Treatment Strategies) project is a screening and assessment initiative based on an easy to perform riskstratification scale (pre-screen), the Risk Instrument for Screening in the Community (RISC) [35][36][37], and a brief comprehensive geriatric assessment instrument, the Community Assessment of Risk Instrument (CARI) [38]. …”

Towards a multidimensional healthy ageing phenotype

“…Frailty indicators have been extensively validated in multiple populations for their ability to predict age-related adverse health outcomes ranging from falls to mortality in elderly populations (14). Measures of frailty have been reviewed recently by who showed that different instruments captured different characteristics of frailty and that whether an individual is classified as frail or not depends on the index of frailty used in the assessment (15).…”