Risk prediction models for colorectal cancer: A Scoping review

Abstract

Background and objectives Many risk prediction models have been developed globally to identify specific populations at high risk for colorectal cancer in specific settings. Documentation of available evidence from existing studies will serve as a useful information base. We performed a scoping review, to review and analyse published risk prediction models for colorectal cancer the world over. Methods A scoping review was undertaken to address the following question 'what are the existing risk prediction models to identify the risk of developing colorectal cancer among individuals in different countries and settings?' using the framework developed by Arksey and O'Malley for scoping reviews. Forty-one articles were included in this review from database searches and from additional searches. The titles and abstracts were reviewed using predetermined screening criteria. We limited our search to existing literature in English language and included both observational and interventional studies. Results Out of the 58 risk prediction models identified, most were developed for colorectal cancer followed by advanced colorectal cancer. Most of the articles reviewed were cross sectional studies or cohort studies. Statistical methods such as multiple logistic regression was used by a majority, while few have incorporated non-statistical methods such as consensus method and extracting data from published literature. The authors of the 58 risk prediction models have considered 77 different risk factors excluding the genetic variants. Conclusions This comprehensive scoping review demonstrates the capacity of the existing risk models to stratify the general population into risk categories, detailing the studies conducted, location, study design, outcome, overview of the methods, data source and the identified risk predictors. While striving to build on existing knowledge, the review also identifies the research gaps and the need for further improvement.

Preventing colorectal cancer in Sri Lanka: step forward

“…Samarakoon et al (2017) conducted a comprehensive scoping review on the available risk models and scores for colorectal cancer, and thereby identify the need for further improvement (24). Out of the 58 risk prediction models identified, most had been developed for advanced colorectal cancer.…”