Risks, Resilience, and Reforms: Indonesia’s Financial System in 2019

Abstract

Indonesia has managed the complex challenges of the global economy well. The country's capital outflows were smaller in 2018 than during the Taper Tantrum in 2013; the rupiah had regained most of its lost ground by January 2019; the Indonesian stock market has outperformed its peers; growth is forecast to remain stable; inflation is low; unemployment remains below its five-year average; consumer and business confidence are robust; and the government budget has improved through a smaller deficit and cheaper borrowing costs. But significant risks remain. This paper assesses these risks and evaluates the adequacy of Indonesia's crisis management framework. It finds that the framework has serious deficiencies that could see liquidity challenges become systemic solvency crises. The framework effectively removes Bank Indonesia as the lender of last resort, risks politicising the process of crisis response, and could mean slower, less effective responses to crises. This paper explores how the framework could be improved and what reforms could be undertaken to deepen Indonesia's financial system, strengthen financial resilience, and boost the long-term growth outlook.

The Bank Specific Determinants of Loan Growth and Stability: Evidence from Indonesia

“…However, there are still weaknesses in the current regulatory banking framework. According to Triggs et al (2019), the Financial System Stability Committee (KKSK) may undermine the independence of BI, OJK, and LPS. In the event of an illiquid or insolvent bank, BI, which is deemed the lender of last resort, has to discuss (or even to seek approval) with its counterparts in the KKSK whether to bail the bank out or not.…”

Managing Recovery and Seizing Reform Opportunities

“…Indonesia's financial market is small and shallow, and the financial system is skewed towards banks with small pools of long-term institutional investors, such as pension funds and insurance. A deeper financial market with more long-term institutional investors could provide the finance needed for economic development and reduce reliance on foreign finance (see IMF 2018;Triggs, Kacaribu and Wang 2019). In addition, the government needs to improve the effectiveness of its fiscal spending and revenue collection.…”

The Struggle to Recruit Good Teachers in Indonesia: Institutional and Social Dysfunctions

“…Education spending consists of 20% of the national budget (Kementerian Keuangan Republik Indonesia, n.d.), and promoting all of the country's contract teachers on top of existing teacher corps and future civil service hiring is fiscally impossible. Increasing the number of teachers employed by the state will add to Indonesia's financial burden at a time when the government is dealing with the COVID-19 pandemic; concerned in boosting the infrastructure development (Suhartono and Salna, 2019); facing slower economic growth (Dong and Manning, 2017); having limited fiscal flexibility to respond to systemic shocks (Triggs, Kacaribu and Wang, 2019), and close to the 3% legal limit to budget deficit (Hamilton-Hart and Schultze, 2017).…”