When Apirion first proposed that mRNA decay in Escherichia coli involves a series of endo-and exonucleolytic events (2), the general working assumption was that the turnover of transcripts is a simple salvage pathway that is necessary for recycling of ribonucleotides. Although experimental data at that time indicated that mRNAs are rapidly degraded (11,40) and that decay of individual transcripts is independent of length (9), the number and specificities of the enzymes that actually carry out transcript degradation were still open questions. Twenty-nine years and many experiments later, a much different picture has emerged. Not only is the pathway of mRNA decay far more complex than originally envisioned, but it apparently also plays an integral role in regulating the expression of many genes. While many important features of this system remain to be elucidated, this prospective attempts to convey the current state of knowledge. In addition, it focuses primarily on those areas where there are disagreements regarding important features of the mRNA decay process.
INITIATION OF mRNA DECAYOf all of the aspects associated with mRNA decay in E. coli, the question of how the process is initiated has sparked the most controversy. Not only have there been conflicting views regarding which enzyme(s) is responsible for the initial endonucleolytic cleavage events, but there have also been disagreements regarding the importance of certain multiprotein complexes. E. coli is known to contain at least five endoribonucleases: RNases III, E, G, and I/M.RNase III was first discovered as a protein that cleaves double-stranded RNA (94). In vivo, RNase III specifically degrades stem-loop structures, particularly those in intercistronic regions (34, 88). It plays a major role in processing of the 30S rRNA precursor (34). The enzyme has been shown to indirectly affect the half-lives of a limited number of transcripts (7,36,88), primarily by eliminating a stem-loop structure, usually upstream of the translation start site. However, deletion of the RNase III structural gene (rnc) does not lead to any significant change in the degradation of total pulse-labeled RNA or specific transcripts (5). Thus, it is probably not a major player in mRNA decay.In 1979, Ono and Kuwano (84) isolated a temperaturesensitive mutation, called ams-1 (for altered mRNA stability), that led to a slowing in the decay of total pulse-labeled RNA.Independently, Ghora and Apirion (37) identified RNase E on the basis of its role in the processing of 9S rRNA into a 5S form. More than a decade later, several laboratories showed that the ams-1 and rne-3071 mutations are alleles of the same gene, now called rne (6,68,77,105).In addition to being required for the maturation of 9S rRNA, RNase E has also been shown to be involved in the processing of the 5Ј end of 16S rRNA (54, 111), the maturation of the RNA subunit of RNase P (63), the degradation of the antisense inhibitor (RNA I) of plasmid colE1 DNA replication (107), and the processing of tRNAs (53, 85, 92). As such, i...