Robotic MLC‐based plans: A study of plan complexity

Abstract

Purpose The utility of complexity metrics has been assessed for IMRT and VMAT treatment plans, but this analysis has never been performed for CyberKnife (CK) plans. The purpose of this study is to perform a complexity analysis of CK MLC plans, adapting and computing complexity indices previously defined for IMRT plans. Metrics were used to compare the complexity of plans created by two optimization systems and to study correlations between plan complexity and patient‐specific quality assurance (PSQA) results. Relationships between pairs of metrics were also analyzed to get insight into possible interdependencies. Methods Two independent in‐house software platforms were developed to compute six complexity metrics: modulation complexity score (MCS), edge metric (EM), plan irregularity (PI), plan modulation (PM), leaf gap (LG), and small aperture score (SAS10). MCS and PM definitions were adapted to account for CK plans characteristics. The computed metrics were used to compare the existing optimization algorithms (sequential and VOLO) in terms of plan complexity over 24 selected cases. Metrics were then computed over a large number (103) of VOLO SBRT clinical plans from different treatment sites, mainly liver, prostate, pancreas, and spine. Pearson's r was used to study relationships between each pair of metrics. Correlation between complexity indices and PSQA results expressed as gamma index passing rates (GPR) at (3%, 1 mm) and (2%, 1 mm) was finally analyzed. Correlation was regarded as weak for absolute Pearson’s r values in the range 0.2–0.39, moderate 0.4–0.59, strong 0.6−0.79, and very strong 0.8–1. Results When compared to VOLO, sequential plans exhibited a higher complexity degree, showing lower MCS and LG values and higher EM, PM and PI values. Differences were significant for 5/6 metrics (Wilcoxon P < 0.05). The analysis of VOLO clinical plans highlighted different degrees of complexity among plans from different treatment sites, increasing from liver to prostate, pancreas, and finally, spine. Analysis of dependencies between pairs of metrics showed a very strong significant negative correlation (P < 0.01), respectively, between MCS and PM (r = −0.97), and EM and LG (−0.82). Most of the remaining pairs showed moderate to strong correlations with the exception of PI, which showed weaker correlations with the other metrics. A moderate significant correlation was observed with GPR values both at (3%, 1 mm) and (2%, 1 mm) for all metrics except PI, which showed no correlation. Conclusions Modulation complexity metrics were computed for CK MLC‐based plans for the first time and some metrics' definitions were adapted to CK plans peculiarities. The computed metrics proved a useful tool for comparing optimization algorithms and for characterizing CK clinical plans. Strong and very strong correlations were found between some pairs of metrics. Some significant correlations were found with PSQA GPR, indicating that some indices are promising for rationalizing and reducing PSQA workload. Our results set the basis fo...

Plan quality assessment in clinical practice: Results of the 2020 ESTRO survey on plan complexity and robustness

“…In the questions concerning plan complexity, no distinction was made between photon and proton centres. Traditionally, plan complexity has been described mainly in the context of photon treatments with conventional linear accelerators, but some complexity metrics may be valid for other techniques such as robotic radiosurgery [46]. We believe similar concepts that reduce complexity and increase efficiency could also be applied to proton therapy.…”

Identification of hub genes related to immune cell infiltration in periodontitis using integrated bioinformatic analysis

“…Spearman correlation analysis was calculated between hub genes and the relative proportions of immune cells. Pheatmap package was applied to visualize the results with p < .05 and | r | > 0.6 32 …”

Patient specific quality assurance in SBRT: a systematic review of measurement-based methods

“…Modest correlations were found between plan complexity and PSQA GPR both in the case of CyberKnife and C-arm Linac. Correlation largely depends on delivery platform and measurement device but MLC Equivalent Field Size, Modulation Complexity Score and Plan Modulation seem the most promising indices for rationalizing and reducing the PSQA workload in CK and VMAT plans (Chun et al 2019, Xia et al 2020, Masi et al 2021.…”