We introduce a combinatorial argument to study closed minimal hypersurfaces of bounded area and high Morse index. Let (M n+1 , g) be a closed Riemannian manifold and Σ ⊂ M be a closed embedded minimal hypersurface with area at most A > 0 and with a singular set of Hausdorff dimension at most n− 7. We show the following bounds: there is C A > 0 depending only on n, g, and A so that, where b i denote the Betti numbers over any field, H n−7 is the (n − 7)dimensional Hausdorff measure and Sing(Σ) is the singular set of Σ. In fact in dimension n + 1 = 3, C A depends linearly on A. We list some open problems at the end of the paper.