Retinoblastoma tumor suppressor proteins are highly conserved transcriptional corepressors, regulating the key transition from G1 to S phase of the cell cycle. The mammalian Rb family is composed of Rb, p107, and p130, which possess both overlapping and unique roles in gene regulation. Likewise, the Drosophila lineage experienced a gene duplication event, leading to the expression of the Rbf1 and Rbf2 paralogs. To uncover the significance of the multiplicity of the Rb family, and how gene regulatory roles have been apportioned between the family members, we made use of the CRISPRi system. We engineered dCas9 fusions to Rbf1 and Rbf2, and deployed them to gene promoters in developing Drosophila tissue to study their relative impact on target promoters. On some genes, both Rbf1 and Rbf2 are able to mediate potent repression, and this happens in a distance-dependent manner. In general, a greater repression effect is noted for promoter-proximal sites, suggesting that Rb proteins have short-range effects, and may directly impact function of the basal transcriptional machinery. Depending on context, Rbf1 or Rbf2 was more potent, suggesting that the paralogs possess non-identical functions, possibly due to primary sequence divergence. Notably, with this dCas9 tethering system, an Rbf1 mutant lacking the entire pocket domain, that has been generally assumed to be necessary for function, retained repression activity. Significantly, direct comparison of Rb activity on endogenous genes and transiently transfected reporters showed that only qualitative, but not key quantitative aspects of repression were conserved, indicating that the native chromatin environment is essential for understanding the context-specific effects of Rb activity. The data presented here points to the complexity of Rb-mediated transcriptional regulation in a living organism, undoubtedly impacted by the different promoter landscapes and the evolution of the Rb proteins themselves.