Role of Moderators on Engagement of Adolescents With Depression or Anxiety in a Social Media Intervention: Content Analysis of Web-Based Interactions

Abstract

Background The Supporting Our Valued Adolescents (SOVA) intervention aims to use a moderated social media website to encourage peer discussion about negative health beliefs, which may prevent treatment uptake. Web moderators with a background in behavioral health are used to facilitate peer conversation to promote a sense of community, provide social support, and ensure safety. Objective Although moderation is a core component of this intervention, little is known on best practices for moderators to ensure safety while encouraging engagement. This study sought to describe interactions between moderators and peer users and understand moderator experiences through individual interviews. Methods Adolescents and young adults aged 14 to 26 years with depression or anxiety history were recruited for a usability study of the SOVA intervention. During this study, 14 moderators were trained to regularly review comments to blog posts for safety, facilitate conversation, and correct misinformation. A total of 110 blog posts and their associated comments were extracted and coded using a codebook based on items from the supportive accountability model and a peer social support analysis. Closing interviews with 12 moderators assessing their experience of moderating were conducted, recorded, and transcribed. Blog post text and comments as well as transcripts of moderator interviews were assessed using a thematic analysis approach, and blog posts were examined for trends in content of moderator comments comparing blog posts with differences in comment contributor order. Results There were no safety concerns during the study, and moderators only intervened to remove identifiable information. Web moderators exhibited elements of supportive accountability (such as being perceived as experts and using verbal rewards as well as offering informational and emotional support). When the moderators provided the last comment under a blog post, thereby potentially ending contribution by users, they were at times found to be commenting about their own experiences. Moderators interviewed after completing their role expressed challenges in engaging users. A cohort of moderators who received more extensive training on supportive accountability and peer social support felt their ability to engage users improved because of the training. Conclusions Moderators of a Web-based support site for adolescents with depression or anxiety were able to ensure safety while promoting user engagement. Moderators can elicit user engagement by offering gratitude and encouragement to users, asking users follow-up questions, and limiting their own opinions and experiences when responding to comments.

Receptiveness and Responsiveness Toward Using Social Media for Safe Firearm Storage Outreach: Mixed Methods Study

“…This observation begins to highlight the emerging importance of engaging positive influencers on social media for promotion of events such as the SFSGOE. Other studies have also highlighted the importance of having “moderated” discussions, which have been shown to yield better participant engagement and to promote a safer discussion environment [ 26 , 27 ].…”

Social Media Use in Emerging Adults: Investigating the Relationship With Social Media Addiction and Social Behavior

“…When treating these individuals, it is important to explore different approaches for fulfilling attention and approval needs rather than depending on social media. For example, clinicians could explore interventions such as The Supporting Our Valued Adolescents (SOVA) web based intervention that targets approval and esteem in adolescents and young adults with depression or anxiety (Windler et al, 2019). Future research could focus on creating such interventions for this population as they may help teach healthy social media behaviors while also meeting attention and approval needs.…”

Website sobre sexualidade e prevenção de infecções sexualmente transmissíveis para adolescentes católicos

“…Em estudo realizado sobre a moderação de conversas entre adolescentes, os autores reforçam a importância do moderador para equilibrar a função de vigilância, possibilitando a função de suporte social e facilitador da conversa para promover suporte social entre os pares na web. (32) Sobre o conteúdo, todos os itens obtiveram índices >0,80. Não há dúvidas de que uma tecnologia no formato virtual apresenta eficácia com adolescentes.…”