Benzoic
acid–monofluorobenzoic acid combinations are known
to form solid solutions, whereas benzoic acid–pentafluorobenzoic
acid system forms a cocrystal. To decipher the gradation from solid
solution to cocrystal between these extremes, we executed the cocrystallization
of benzoic acid with several of its poly-fluoro (di-, tri-, and tetra-)
substituents. The fluorine atom, with its sheer geometric position
and intermolecular (hydrogen and halogen) bonding ability, is found
to steer the transformation from a solid solution to a cocrystal in
this family of compounds. We found, among others, a novel crystal
entity in the benzoic acid–3,4,5-trifluorobenzoic acid combination
that shows characteristics of both a solid solution (a single disordered
molecule in the crystallographic asymmetric unit) and a cocrystal
(a distinct crystal structure as compared with the parent compounds).
This solid solution-cum-cocrystal therefore acts
a connecting link in the evolution of cocrystals from solid solutions
in benzoic acid–fluorobenzoic acid systems. In addition, the
cocrystallization of benzoic acid with 2,6-difluorobenzoic acid and
2,4,6-trifluorobenzoic acid resulted in eutectics, which appears to
be due to the supramolecular incompatibility invoked by out-of-plane
carboxylic acid in the latter compounds.