Rural Europe Redux? Reflections on Alternative Agro‐Food Networks and Paradigm Change

Abstract

This paper examines some recent analyses of alternative agro‐food networks (AAFNs) and claims that these innovative modes of food provisioning are emblematic of a new rural development paradigm in Western Europe. A political‐economic critique of the territorialised, farm‐centric value added strategies underlying these claims suggests that this characterisation is overdrawn and premature. The neglect of the consumption side of the rural development equation also argues for a more modest assessment of AAFNs and their paradigmatic potential.

Les systèmes agroalimentaires alternatifs. Une revue de travaux anglophones en sciences sociales

“…Si on ne peut reprocher aux auteurs de ne pas traiter de la relation entre S3A et famine, on peut cependant soulever quelques interrogations sur la relation entre une saisonnalité et une proximité revendiquées de l'approvisionnement et les exigences d'une alimentation régulière et diversifiée 13 . Des auteurs soulignent d'ailleurs le risque que les S3A contribuent à renverser le processus de démocratisation de l'accès à la nourriture historiquement mis en place par le système conventionnel, créant de nouvelles rentes de situation (Goodman, 2004). Certains acteurs des S3A, plutôt que de vouloir créer des systèmes proprement alternatifs au sens de « à côté », oeuvrent d'ailleurs en faveur d'une pression sur le système dominant visant la redéfini-tion des relations qu'il entretient avec les consommateurs.…”

Biosphere reserves and their contribution to sustainable development

“…According to , such shift is a new "rural development paradigm". In this context the question arises, whether rural development represents a qualitatively different development model (Van der PloeG / rentinG 2004) or whether it can be understood within the framework of modernization (further development of multifunctionality and endogenous development) (GoodMan 2004). darnhoFer (2005,309) concludes in this context that "it is less an either/or choice, but rather the two poles of a continuum" and Van der PloeG et al (2000, 391) stress that the term rural development is widely used, "but there is still no comprehensive and agreed-upon definition of it".…”

Rural development strategies and government roles in the development of farmers’ cooperatives in China

“…All three engaged in ecological agriculture (green, hazard-free food and organic agriculture in our cases), which helps to build soil fertility and minimize environmental externalities. Localized food supply chains established by the Daizhuang and Tonglu FPCs reduce the distance that food travels from the site of production to consumption, thereby reducing the need for long-distance food transport and its associated energy emissions (Goodman, 2004). Agritourism can help improve the awareness of environmental problems among both farmers and urban visitors (Brodt, Feenstra, Kozloff, Klonsky, & Tourte, 2006).…”