Rural, Suburban, and Urban Differences in Factors That Impact Physician Adherence to Clinical Preventive Service Guidelines

Abstract

Purpose Rural-urban disparities in provision of preventive services exist, but there is sparse research on how rural, suburban, or urban differences impact physician adherence to clinical preventive service guidelines. We aimed to identify factors that may cause differences in adherence to preventive service guidelines among rural, suburban, and urban primary care physicians. Methods This qualitative study involved in-depth semi-structured interviews with 29 purposively sampled primary care physicians (10 rural, 10 suburban, 9 urban) in Missouri. Physicians were asked to describe barriers and facilitators to clinical preventive service guideline adherence. Using techniques from grounded theory analysis, 2 coders first independently conducted content analysis then reconciled differences in coding to ensure agreement on intended meaning of transcripts. Findings Patient epidemiologic differences, distance to health care services, and care coordination were reported as prominent factors that produced differences in preventive service guideline adherence among rural, suburban, and urban physicians. Epidemiologic differences impacted all physicians, but rural physicians highlighted the importance of occupational risk factors in their patients. Greater distance to health care services reduced visit frequency and was a prominent barrier for rural physicians. Care coordination among health care providers was problematic for suburban and urban physicians. Patient resistance to medical care and inadequate access to resources and specialists were identified as barriers by some rural physicians. Conclusions The rural, suburban, or urban context impacts whether a physician will adhere to clinical preventive service guidelines. Efforts to increase guideline adherence should consider the barriers and facilitators unique to rural, suburban, or urban areas.

Preventive Dental Checkups and Their Association With Access to Usual Source of Care Among Rural and Urban Adult Residents

“…There are fewer oral health care providers and other health care workers in rural regions of the country . Changing the delivery model may improve access.…”

Sexual Health Care Services Among Young Adult Sexual Minority Women

“…Additionally, health care providers working outside of urban areas may face challenges to adhering to clinical guidelines not experienced by providers practicing in urban settings. A qualitative study of physicians practicing in urban, suburban, and rural environments reported concerns about societal norms and priorities, general agreement with specific guidelines, and patient-physician relationships as factors that more commonly influence non-urban providers’ adherence to preventive service guidelines (Khoong, Gibbert, Garbutt, Sumner, & Brownson, 2014). Future research examining geographic disparities in sexual health service utilization among sexual minorities may be warranted.…”

Health IT-Enabled Care Coordination: A National Survey of Patient-Centered Medical Home Clinicians

“…Another study reported that urban and suburban physicians have difficulty coordinating patient care because their patients belong to multiple medical systems. 18 Limitations By design, we sampled practices that were poised for implementation of MU stage 3 based on their adoption of PCMH and participation in MU stage 1. Our findings thus should represent a best-case scenario.…”