Saiga horn user characteristics, motivations, and purchasing behaviour in Singapore

Abstract

Unsustainable wildlife trade is a pervasive issue affecting wildlife globally. To address this issue, a plethora of demand reduction efforts have been carried out. These necessitate consumer research which provides crucial knowledge for designing and evaluating targeted interventions. We implemented a rigorous consumer survey on saiga (Saiga tatarica) horn use in Singapore, where usage is legal and widely sold. Saiga are Critically Endangered antelopes from Central Asia with horns (often marketed as ling yang) used in traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). Few past studies have assessed saiga horn consumers. This work is the most extensive consumer research to date specifically characterising saiga horn consumers and usage. We conducted 2294 in-person surveys on saiga horn use with Chinese Singaporeans, employing neutral questioning approaches. We found 19% of individuals reported saiga horn as a product they choose most often for themselves and/or others when treating fever and/or heatiness (a TCM state of illness), indicating a minimum estimate of high-frequency usage, not including possible low-frequency users. Overall saiga users were most characterised as middle-aged Buddhists and Taoists. However, saiga users were found in a range of demographic groups. Women preferred saiga shavings (the more traditional form), while men preferred saiga cooling water (the more modern form). About 53% of individuals who used saiga horn themselves also bought it for someone else. Buyers for others were most likely to be female middle-aged Buddhists or Taoists. Key motivating reasons for usage were “it works” and “someone recommended it to me.” The top two reported recommenders were family and TCM shopkeepers. Saiga users were more likely than non-saiga users to perceive saiga as a common species in the wild. This research holds significance for interventions targeting saiga horn consumption within Singapore and throughout Asia, by identifying potential target audiences, product types, non-desirable alternatives, and motivations for use.

Knowledge and attitudes about the use of pangolin scale products in Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) within China

“…The few existing studies of pangolin scale trade have focused only on the presence/absence of illegal scale trade or analysing illegal trade reports, which revealed important findings such as the widespread availability of illegal products in TCM markets and key transit cities along illegal trading routes (Cheng, Xing, & Bonebrake, 2017;Xu et al, 2016;Yin et al, 2015). However, knowledge and attitudes of TCM practitioners about pangolin scale medicines are also crucial for regulating pangolin scale trade, since this stakeholder group has the potential to influence consumer behaviours and decide or guide consumption (Doughty et al, 2019;Tan & Freathy, 2011).…”

Korean ‘Housewives’ and ‘Hipsters’ Are Not Driving a New Illicit Plant Trade: Complicating Consumer Motivations Behind an Emergent Wildlife Trade in Dudleya farinosa

“…Understanding the complexities and motivations of parties engaged in the purchasing of illicitly traded wildlife products is essential for informing effective, socially just and responsible interventions to effectively curtail IWT and promote sustainable wildlife trades (Wyatt, 2009;Duffy et al, 2016;Doughty et al, 2019;Thomas-Walters et al, 2020b). Echoing the sentiments of others, research into the underpinnings of the illicit trade in D. farinosa speaks to the greater need for deeper interdisciplinary conversation and engagement between criminologists, conservation scientists, geographers and anthropologists in IWT-related research in order to inform more sustainable plant trades (Blair et al, 2017;Boratto and Gibbs, 2019;Gore et al, 2019).…”

“…Inductive theoretical codes emergent from this process were applied to interview transcripts and managed within the qualitative data analysis software NVivo (QSR International). This inductive research approach was more appropriate to this study of D. farinosa trade than other research methods such as larger consumer-oriented surveys for several reasons (e.g., Doughty et al, 2019). First, there was no baseline data from which to support a survey tool or other statistically robust form of measurement.…”

Influencing consumer demand is vital for tackling the illegal wildlife trade

“…price, availability, provenance) that a consumer may seek, but also by the consumers' identity and economic constraints (e.g. ethnicity, religion, income) as well as the sociocultural context in which purchase and consumption takes place (Doughty et al, 2019;Thomas-Walters, Cheung, et al, 2020;Thomas-Walters, Hinsley, et al, 2020). The latter context also includes the marketing activities of suppliers and other market actors who effectively try to influence consumer demand.…”