The three closely related species that currently comprise the genus Salinispora were analyzed using a multilocus sequence typing approach targeting 48 strains derived from four geographic locations. Phylogenetic congruence and a well-supported concatenated tree provide strong support for the delineation of the three species as currently described and the basal relationship of Salinispora arenicola to the more recently diverged sister taxa S. tropica and S. pacifica. The phylogeny of the initial region of the rpoB gene sequenced was atypical, placing the related genera Micromonospora and Verrucosispora within the Salinispora clade. This phylogenetic incongruence was subsequently ascribed to a homologous-recombination event in a portion of the gene associated with resistance to compounds in the rifamycin class, which target RpoB. All S. arenicola strains produced compounds in this class and possessed resistance-conferring amino acid changes in RpoB. The phylogeny of a region of the rpoB gene that is not associated with rifamycin resistance was congruent with the other housekeeping genes. The link between antibiotic resistance and homologous recombination suggests that incongruent phylogenies provide opportunities to identify the molecular targets of secondary metabolites, an observation with potential relevance for drug discovery efforts. Low ratios of interspecies recombination to mutation, even among cooccurring strains, coupled with high levels of within-species recombination suggest that the three species have been described in accordance with natural barriers to recombination.
It has become clear that rates of homologous recombination can be extensive within bacterial species (1-3). This process, coupled with barriers to interspecies recombination (4), provides a mechanism of genetic cohesion that shares features with the biological species concept (5). In comparison, the stableecotype model suggests that genetic cohesion is maintained within ecologically distinct populations largely by periodic selection events and low rates of recombination relative to mutation (6-8). These contrasting concepts of the evolutionary processes that maintain species level units of diversity are clouded by evidence of interspecies recombination (9, 10), the rates of which vary widely among bacteria (11). Homologous recombination between different bacterial species has not only generated questions about our ability to resolve species using sequence-based phylogenetic approaches, but also whether bacteria merit species level designations (12,13).Multilocus sequence typing (MLST) is based on the sequencing of 5 to 7 housekeeping genes (450 to 500 bp each) that are spread around the chromosome (14). The technique has been used to aid in the classification of bacteria (15,16) and to address linkage equilibrium, gene exchange within and among species, and the relative importance of recombination versus mutation in the maintenance of population genetic structure (2,9,(17)(18)(19). The analysis of MLST data is thus providing new opportu...