Mealybugs are major insect pests of greenhouses, interiorscapes, and conservatories feeding on a wide range of horticultural crops. However, mealybugs are difficult to regulate with insecticides as a result of the presence of a nearly impervious protective waxy covering, which means that alternative management strategies are required. As such, this study was designed to determine the value of applying silicon-based fertilizers such as potassium silicate to fiddleleaf fig, Ficus lyrata, plants as a means of alleviating outbreaks of the citrus mealybug, Planococcus citri. The study evaluated the effects of applying a commercially available silicon-based fertilizer product, ProTek® 0-0-3 The Silicon Solution, as a drench to the growing medium at different rates (0, 100, 400, 800, and 1600 ppm silicon). We determined the effect of the silicon-based fertilizer rate treatments on citrus mealybug life history parameters, including number of eggs laid by the female, body size (mm), and development time (days) from first instar to ovipositing adult female. In addition, we used a plant alkaline fusion technique to assess the concentration (mg·kg−1 or ppm) of silicon in the aboveground tissues (leaves and stems) of fiddleleaf fig plants at variable time intervals (days). This technique involves dry-ashing plant tissue in a muffle furnace followed by alkaline fusion and then colorimetric analysis. We found that the silicon-based fertilizer rate treatments did not negatively affect any of the citrus mealybug life history parameters measured. Citrus mealybug female egg load ranged from 132.3 to 159.2 and the development time (days) ranged from 66.9 to 68.7 d. The silicon concentrations present in the fiddleleaf fig plants on the final harvest date were between 4419.2 and 7241.7 mg·kg−1 silicon with fiddleleaf fig plants that received the 1600 ppm silicon-based fertilizer rate treatment having the highest silicon concentration. Moisture content was not significantly different among plants receiving the different silicon concentrations. Our results seem to suggest that fiddleleaf fig may actually be a silicon “rejector” and, as such, applications of silicon-based fertilizers are not beneficial to fiddleleaf fig plants because they do not accumulate sufficient quantities of silicon to impact citrus mealybugs.