The evolution of granular shear flow is investigated as a function of height in a split-bottom Couette cell. Using particle tracking, magnetic-resonance imaging, and large-scale simulations we find a transition in the nature of the shear as a characteristic height H * is exceeded. Below H * there is a central stationary core; above H * we observe the onset of additional axial shear associated with torsional failure. Radial and axial shear profiles are qualitatively different: the radial extent is wide and increases with height while the axial width remains narrow and fixed.PACS numbers: 45.70. Mg, 83.50.Ax Shear bands in dense granular materials are localized regions of large velocity gradients; they are the antithesis of the broad uniform flows seen in slowly-sheared Newtonian fluids [1,2,3,4,5,6]. Until recently it was generally assumed that all granular shear bands were narrow. However, in 2003 Fenistein et al. [7] discovered that in modified Couette cells granular shear bands can be made arbitrarily broad. In this geometry, the bottom of a cylindrical container is split at radius r = R s and shear is produced by rotating both the outer ring and the cylindrical boundary of the container while keeping the central disk (r < R s ) stationary. For very shallow packs, the shear band measured at the top surface is narrow and located at r = R s so that the inner region directly above the central disk is stationary while the remaining part rotates as a solid. As the filling height of the material, H, increases, the shear band increases in radial width and moves toward the cylinder axis. For sufficiently large H, the shear band overlaps the axis at r = 0 and one might expect qualitatively new behavior. Indeed, Unger et al. [8] predicted that the shape of the boundary between moving and stationary material would undergo a first-order transition as H is increased past a threshold value H * : the shearing region which for H < H * is open at the top and intersects the free surface abruptly collapses to a closed cupola completely buried inside the bulk.Previous experiments focused primarily on the surface flows in shallow containers and left unexplored many questions about the shape and evolution of the shear profiles for large H. Here, we combine magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and high-speed video observations with large-scale simulations to explore shear flow both for shallow and tall packs. In addition to monitoring the evolution of the flow profiles in the radial direction, we also examine shear in the vertical direction. Instead of a first order collapse of the shear zone as proposed by Unger et al.[8], we find that above H * ≃ 0.6R s , the inner core of immobile material disappears gradually as shear along the central axis of the cylinder sets in. Our setup is similar to that of Fenistein et al. [7] except that we rotate the inner disk instead of the outer ring and cylinder (Fig.1b inset). In the absence of inertial effects, this makes no difference to the results. For surface observations with high-speed video ...