Satisfaction in Academic Otolaryngology: Do Physician Demographics Impact Press Ganey Survey Scores?

Abstract

Objectives/Hypothesis Patient satisfaction is increasingly emphasized and measured in healthcare delivery. However, patient satisfaction is multifactorial and difficult to comprehensively assess. The objective of this study was to assess for correlation between patient satisfaction measured by Press Ganey surveys (PGS) and physician demographics of gender, years in practice, academic rank, and specialty in academic otolaryngology. Study Design Review of publicly available PGS scores in academic otolaryngology practice. Methods Public websites of academic otolaryngology departments were assessed for inclusion of PGS scores. Individual physician profiles were queried for years in practice, academic rank, and specialty. Gender was determined by picture or profile pronouns. Univariate and multivariate analyses compared PGS scores with studied variables. Results Forty‐seven of 113 (42.8%) academic practices publicly reported physician PGS score. Of 1,360 affiliated otolaryngologists, 742 (54.6%,592 male:150 female) revealed PGS scores. Average PGS score for male and female providers was equivalent (PGS = 4.73, P = .84). There was no significant difference in PGS scores by academic rank (P = .28). A weak statistically significant decrease in mean PGS scores was associated with longer duration of practice (r = −0.11, P = .018). Head and neck oncologic surgeons had higher mean PGS score in comparison to other specialties (PGS = 4.81, P < .05). General/comprehensive otolaryngologists had lower average PGS score (PGS = 4.66) in comparison to specialists (P < .05). Conclusions Physician gender and academic rank do not correlate with patient satisfaction in academic otolaryngology as measured by publicly reported PGS scores. Head and neck oncology is rated more highly than other specialties, and physicians in practice for longer demonstrate decreased PGS scores. With PGS scores tied to physician evaluation and reimbursement, investigation into the generalizability of PGS in otolaryngology is warranted. Level of Evidence NA Laryngoscope, 130: 1902–1906, 2020

Publicly Reported Patient Satisfaction Scores in Academic Otolaryngology Departments

“…Consistent with the findings in a similar study by Tracy et al, we did not find significant associations between PSS and provider gender or credentials 26 . Though Tracy et al found a weakly statistically significant decrease in mean scores was associated with longer duration of practice, we did not find a significant association between PSS and provider years of experience.…”

Perception of male otolaryngologists on gender discrimination: a comparative study

“…As a matter of fact, patients' gender preference may differ depending on subspecialty; for example, head and neck oncology patients prefer males, while females are more preferred in pediatric otolaryngology [18]. On contrary, potential impact of physician's gender on patients' preference is not demonstrated in a study by Tracy LF et al [19].…”

Are Spanish‐Speaking Families Less Satisfied with Care in Pediatric Otolaryngology?

“…Patient and family satisfaction is key to evaluating the quality of care, reimbursement, and certification requirements in all fields, including otolaryngology 1,4–6 . Although research examining family satisfaction in otolaryngology is increasing, most studies have focused on how differences in provider demographics, specialty, practice setting, as well as patient age and disease‐specific measures, affect satisfaction 4,7–10 . In otolaryngology, there is little research examining the intersection of health equity and family experience 11, 12 …”