Reinforced concrete (RC) and prestressed concrete (PC) structural elements need to be designed in order to guarantee large plastic deformations, avoiding any loss in their load bearing capacity. In this framework, the rotation capacity of RC and PC beams has been demonstrated to be a function of concrete mechanical properties, reinforcement characteristics, and of the structural size. On the other hand, Theory of Plasticity as well as the International Standards completely disregard size‐scale effects and ductile‐to‐brittle transitions, leading to an overlook of the strain‐softening behavior of the concrete matrix and of the rotation capacity of RC beams. On the other hand, the Cohesive/Overlapping Crack Model is able to evaluate concrete cracking in tension and concrete crushing in compression, as well as snap‐back and snap‐through unstable phenomena, steel yielding and/or slippage. This Nonlinear Fracture Mechanics model predicts a reduction in the moment versus rotation plastic plateau by increasing the beam depth and/or the reinforcement percentage. The numerical investigations carried out on reinforced and prestressed high‐performance concrete beams having rectangular or T‐shaped cross‐sections highlight the size‐scale effects on plastic rotation capacity that allow to formulate new scale‐dependent upper and lower limits of reinforcement percentage to guarantee a stable and ductile postpeak behavior of reinforced concrete structures.