The aggregation of the amyloid- (A) peptide plays a pivotal role in the pathogenesis of Alzheimer's disease, as soluble oligomers are intimately linked to neuronal toxicity and inhibition of hippocampal long-term potentiation (LTP). In the C-terminal region of A there are three consecutive GxxxG dimerization motifs, which we could previously demonstrate to play a critical role in the generation of A. Here, we show that glycine 33 (G33) of the central GxxxG interaction motif within the hydrophobic A sequence is important for the aggregation dynamics of the peptide. A peptides with alanine or isoleucine substitutions of G33 displayed an increased propensity to form higher oligomers, which we could attribute to conformational changes. Importantly, the oligomers of G33 variants were much less toxic than A 42 wild type (WT), in vitro and in vivo. Also, whereas A 42 WT is known to inhibit LTP, A 42 G33 variants had lost the potential to inhibit LTP. Our findings reveal that conformational changes induced by G33 substitutions unlink toxicity and oligomerization of A on the molecular level and suggest that G33 is the key amino acid in the toxic activity of A. Thus, a specific toxic conformation of A exists, which represents a promising target for therapeutic interventions.