Scoping Pharmacy Students’ Learning Outcomes: Where Do We Stand?

Abstract

Background: The professional abilities of graduate pharmacists have been associated with pharmacy undergraduates’ educational settings and features. This study aimed to perform a scoping review on how students’ learning outcomes are achieved, including learning assessment strategies, focusing on current pharmacy practice education. Methods: Relevant keywords, e.g., “pharmacy practice”, “(students or undergraduates)” and “outcomes” were browsed in Public/Publisher MEDLINE, Scientific Electronic Library Online, Directory of Open Access Journals, and other relevant databases for recently published sources (2018 and 2017). Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses criteria were followed to assure the scoping quality. All types of students’ learning outcomes were addressed for indexed publications in English, Portuguese or Spanish. Reviews, descriptive studies and commentaries were excluded. Study data are presented in tables comprising objectives, methods, number of participants and main research findings. Results: Overall, 100 studies were identified and 22 were selected. The selected studies were distributed into seven main topics: real practices (n = 9); active-learning strategies (n = 5); comparisons between different teaching pedagogies (n = 3); pharmacy curriculum (n = 2); and other evaluations (n = 3). Conclusions: Studies on pharmacy students’ learning outcomes are limited. Pharmacy undergraduates’ performance was dependent on the learning strategies and extension of syllabus implementation.

Drug design education in China

“…8 Drug design began to move from qualitative to quantitative research, laying theoretical and practical foundations for quantitative drug design, and an independent subdiscipline gradually formed. 9 After the 1970s, drug design began to use methods such as molecular biology, quantum chemistry, basic theories of statistical mathematics, contemporary science and technology, and electronic computers, opening up new dimensions in drug design. With the development of molecular biology, a more in-depth understanding of enzymes and receptors emerged.…”

“…In 1964, Hansch and Fujita Mino proposed a Hansch analysis of the quantitative structure–activity relationship 8 . Drug design began to move from qualitative to quantitative research, laying theoretical and practical foundations for quantitative drug design, and an independent subdiscipline gradually formed 9 . After the 1970s, drug design began to use methods such as molecular biology, quantum chemistry, basic theories of statistical mathematics, contemporary science and technology, and electronic computers, opening up new dimensions in drug design.…”

Online course delivery, assessment, and student satisfaction: The case of Quantitative Chemical Analysis course in the time of COVID-19 pandemic

“…In addition, it is in this area where the fascinating and participatory learning process occurs. Identifying learning outcomes, for example, is the cornerstone upon which the syllabus, content, objectives, assessment, and teaching style (methodology) for a learning unit are built (Hudgens & Chirico, 2010;Yusuff, 2018;Pires & Cavaco, 2019).…”

Characteristics of Different Methods of Training in Mastering the Specialty "Pharmacy"

“…In Japan, patient-centered care is of great importance [9]; in the Netherlands -competence, harmonization of tasks, compliance [10]; in the UK -human factors and ergonomics [11]; in the Eastern Mediterranean and Australia regions, competence-based approach, practical training, and support for the formation of professional identity of pharmacy students [12][13][14]. However, research data on the advantages and disadvantages of learning using different strategies and methods are limited [15,16]. For example, a study of gaming methods in the United States shows that students consider them attractive and pleasant [17].…”