A rigorous test of important theoretical models for permeability of glass‐fiber wicks, backed by numerical simulations, is conducted using a novel small‐scale experiment. The models include those for flow along and across aligned fibers and for flow through random fibers. The domains for numerical simulations were created by randomly distributed parallel fibers in a cube‐like unit‐cell using Geodict. Two separate simulations were considered: (1) Stokes‐flow solution using GeoDict, (2) Whitaker's closure‐formulation solution using COMSOL. The falling‐head parameter was adapted to measure the permeability along and across the fibers. Multiple measurements were conducted for each of the wicks to establish repeatability and estimate scatter. The permeabilities obtained through experiments matched with those from the theoretical and numerical methods. But numerical permeabilities for the longitudinal flow were exceptionally accurate. Also, the specialized models for longitudinal and transverse flows were more accurate than the random‐fiber models. © 2018 American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE J, 64: 3491–3501, 2018