Screening of Intellectual Maturity: Exploring South African Preschoolers' Scores on the Goodenough-Harris Drawing Test and Teachers' Assessment

Abstract

The present study explored the relationship between South African preschool children's intelligence scores achieved on the Goodenough-Harris Drawing Test (GHD), and the accuracy of teachers' ratings of the human-figure drawings and teachers' general perceptions of children's intellectual maturity. The GHD was administered individually to 30 boys and 30 girls between the ages of 4 and 6 years (M = 4.5. SD = 0.7) from a multicultural (Black, Colored, and White) preschool near the Cape, South Africa. The three class teachers of these preschoolers provided the ratings and perceptions of each child's intellectual maturity. Results indicated that the teachers' assessments of children's intellectual maturity were fairly similar to the formal measures of children's intellectual maturity using human figure drawings and their own perceptions. It appears that teacher ratings of drawings could be relied upon as a means of assessment. General perceptions of children's intellectual maturity should not be solely relied upon, but instead these perceptions should be used as an aid for enhancing the teachers' assessment of children's intellectual maturity in addition to the rating of human figure drawings.

Cognitive and physical development in HIV‐positive children in South Africa and Malawi: A community‐based follow‐up comparison study

“…There are few cognitive screening tools for young children in Sub-Saharan Africa and this test was considered the most appropriate. This revised version of DAP has been previously used in African countries (Lotz, Loxton, Naidoo, 2005; Loxton, Mostert, Moffatt, 2006; Powell, Walker, Rogathe, et al 2015). An age scaled score was recorded for each drawing, and mean scores were calculated (range 40-130).…”

Parenting in Adversity: Effects of Older Caregivers, Biological Carers and Troubled Carers on Child Outcomes in High HIV-Affected Communities

“…Fourteen measures were selected to explore child outcomes, these measures focused on variables representative of or linked to developmental outcomes inclusive of mental health and wellbeing, cognition and educational attainment, positive and negative community interactions, exposure to violence and discipline experience. All measures were selected with a focus on age appropriateness, previous use in sub-Saharan Africa, validation and ease of administration (Loxton et al, 2006 ; Madge et al, 1985 ; Skinner et al, 2014 ).…”