Mapping states with explicit gluonic degrees of freedom in the light sector is a challenge, and has led to controversies in the past. In particular, the experiments have reported two different hybrid candidates with spin-exotic signature, π1(1400) and π1 (1600), which couple separately to ηπ and η π. This picture is not compatible with recent Lattice QCD estimates for hybrid states, nor with most phenomenological models. We consider the recent partial wave analysis of the η ( ) π system by the COMPASS collaboration. We fit the extracted intensities and phases with a coupled-channel amplitude that enforces the unitarity and analyticity of the S-matrix. We provide a robust extraction of a single exotic π1 resonant pole, with mass and width 1564 ± 24 ± 86 MeV and 492 ± 54 ± 102 MeV, which couples to both η ( ) π channels. We find no evidence for a second exotic state. We also provide the resonance parameters of the a2(1320) and a 2 (1700).