“…They are also singly periodic and produce embedded minimal tori in S 2 × S 1 (r) for all r > 0 (see also [20, §7] for a beautiful description). Note that, thanks to [24,Theorem 4.8], a compact minimal surface Σ immersed in S 2 × S 1 (r), r ≥ 1, foliated by circles has index greater than or equal to one (the index is one only for r = 1 and Σ = Γ × S 1 (1), Γ ⊂ S 2 being a great circle). A similar estimation of the index for r < 1 remains an open question (see [24,Remark 4.9]).…”