In an era of widespread extinction and invasion, understanding the functional role of native and introduced birds in ecological processes is increasingly important. This study compared seed rain in the presence and absence of Hawaii's last abundant native frugivore, and found that introduced birds were an imperfect substitute. In the absence of the native bird, seed rain was less frequent, less species rich, and biased towards smaller seeded plants. To maintain diverse island plant communities, conservation strategies in Hawaii should focus on restoring functional populations of native dispersers, rather than relying on introduced species to fill this role.